- address-policy-wg - mailman.ripe.net

Re: [address-policy-wg] 2014-10 New Policy Proposal (Language Clarification in âIPv6 Addresses for Internet Root Servers In The RIPE Regionâ)
by Peter Koch 23 Oct '14

23 Oct '14

On Thu, Oct 23, 2014 at 03:37:23PM +0200, Marco Schmidt wrote: > A proposed change to RIPE Document "IPv6 Addresses for Internet > Root Servers In The RIPE Region" is now available for discussion. > http://www.ripe.net/ripe/policies/proposals/2014-10 1) the motivating pointer to RFC 2119 is misguided. RIPE documents do not make a reference to RFC 2119 in general and even less so in this particular case. There's already enough confusion in the IETF with "must" vs "MUST", i.e., when keywords do and don't bear their special meaning. 2) the change is unnecessary and does not provide clarification. The text is already clearly stating that assigned address space stays with the service and will (have to) be returned to the RIPE NCC if the service is terminated. A "should" is sufficient. 3) The status of ripe-233, especially in the light of the omnibus document ripe-623 is probably a bit vague. ripe-233 exists for historic reference, therefore any change applied by this proposal would retroactively try to change the rule for past assignments with no new assignments to be expected (for lack of policy). 4) Issuing a new document with a new timestamp is likely to cause more confusion than it strives to solve (lacking sth equivalent to a "Historic" document status and/or explanatory introductory text in the updated document). Resolved, no support -Peter

2 1

Five Policy Proposals to Improve RIPE Documents
by Marco Schmidt 23 Oct '14

23 Oct '14

Dear colleagues, Later today, we will publish five policy proposals on the Address Policy Working Group Mailing List. We wanted to let you know in advance what these are about. In the Address Policy WG sessions at RIPE 67 and RIPE 68, it was discussed that the language in several RIPE Documents should be improved by changing instances of “should” to “must” where this was creating unwanted ambiguity. You can find more information here: https://ripe68.ripe.net/presentations/288-APWG-co-presentation-should.pdf After receiving guidance from the RIPE community, RIPE NCC has decided to start the process to clarify the language in these RIPE Documents by submitting these proposals into the PDP. For clarity, and as instructed by the community, there will be one proposal per RIPE Document. If you wish to provide your feedback to a specific proposed change, please make sure that you reply to the appropriate announcement and thread. Kind regards Marco Schmidt Policy Development Officer RIPE NCC

3 2

Re: [address-policy-wg] 2014-10 New Policy Proposal (Language Clarification in “IPv6 Addresses for Internet Root Servers In The RIPE Region”)
by James Blessing 23 Oct '14

23 Oct '14

On 23 October 2014 14:37, Marco Schmidt <mschmidt(a)ripe.net> wrote: > > Dear colleagues, > > > A proposed change to RIPE Document "IPv6 Addresses for Internet > Root Servers In The RIPE Region" is now available for discussion. > > > You can find the full proposal at: > > http://www.ripe.net/ripe/policies/proposals/2014-10 > Support J -- James Blessing 07989 039 476

1 0

Re: [address-policy-wg] 2014-08 New Policy Proposal (Language Clarification in “Contractual Requirements for Provider Independent Resource Holders in the RIPE NCC Service Region”)
by James Blessing 23 Oct '14

23 Oct '14

On 23 October 2014 14:15, Marco Schmidt <mschmidt(a)ripe.net> wrote: > > Dear colleagues, > > > A proposed change to RIPE Document "Contractual Requirements for Provider > Independent Resource Holders in the RIPE NCC Service Region" is now available > for discussion. > > > You can find the full proposal at: > > https://www.ripe.net/ripe/policies/proposals/2014-08 > Support J -- James Blessing 07989 039 476

1 0

Re: [address-policy-wg] 2014-09 New Policy Proposal (Language Clarification in “IPv6 Address Space Policy For Internet Exchange Points”)
by James Blessing 23 Oct '14

23 Oct '14

On 23 October 2014 14:28, Marco Schmidt <mschmidt(a)ripe.net> wrote: > > Dear colleagues, > > > A proposed change to RIPE Document IPv6 Address Space Policy For > Internet Exchange Points is now available for discussion. > > > You can find the full proposal at: > > http://www.ripe.net/ripe/policies/proposals/2014-09 > Support J -- James Blessing 07989 039 476

1 0

Re: [address-policy-wg] 2014-07 New Policy Proposal (Language Clarification in “IPv4 Address Allocation and Assignment Policies for the RIPE NCC Service Region”)
by James Blessing 23 Oct '14

23 Oct '14

On 23 October 2014 14:05, Marco Schmidt <mschmidt(a)ripe.net> wrote: > > Dear colleagues, > > > A proposed change to RIPE Document "IPv4 Address Allocation and Assignment > Policies for the RIPE NCC Service Region" is now available for discussion. > > > You can find the full proposal at: > > https://www.ripe.net/ripe/policies/proposals/2014-07 > Support J -- James Blessing 07989 039 476

1 0

Re: [address-policy-wg] 2014-11 New Policy Proposal (Language Clarification for “Allocating/Assigning Resources to the RIPE NCC”)
by James Blessing 23 Oct '14

23 Oct '14

On 23 October 2014 14:45, Marco Schmidt <mschmidt(a)ripe.net> wrote: > > Dear colleagues, > > > A proposed change to RIPE Document "Allocating/Assigning Resources > to the RIPE NCC" is now available for discussion. > > > You can find the full proposal at: > > http://www.ripe.net/ripe/policies/proposals/2014-11 > > We encourage you to review this proposal and send your comments to > <address-policy-wg(a)ripe.net> before 21 November 2014. Support J -- James Blessing 07989 039 476

1 0

2014-11 New Policy Proposal (Language Clarification for “Allocating/Assigning Resources to the RIPE NCC”)
by Marco Schmidt 23 Oct '14

23 Oct '14

Dear colleagues, A proposed change to RIPE Document "Allocating/Assigning Resources to the RIPE NCC" is now available for discussion. You can find the full proposal at: http://www.ripe.net/ripe/policies/proposals/2014-11 We encourage you to review this proposal and send your comments to <address-policy-wg(a)ripe.net> before 21 November 2014. Regards, Marco Schmidt Policy Development Officer RIPE NCC

1 0

2014-10 New Policy Proposal (Language Clarification in “IPv6 Addresses for Internet Root Servers In The RIPE Region”)
by Marco Schmidt 23 Oct '14

23 Oct '14

Dear colleagues, A proposed change to RIPE Document "IPv6 Addresses for Internet Root Servers In The RIPE Region" is now available for discussion. You can find the full proposal at: http://www.ripe.net/ripe/policies/proposals/2014-10 We encourage you to review this proposal and send your comments to <address-policy-wg(a)ripe.net> before 21 November 2014. Regards, Marco Schmidt Policy Development Officer RIPE NCC

1 0

2014-09 New Policy Proposal (Language Clarification in “IPv6 Address Space Policy For Internet Exchange Points”)
by Marco Schmidt 23 Oct '14

23 Oct '14

Dear colleagues, A proposed change to RIPE Document IPv6 Address Space Policy For Internet Exchange Points is now available for discussion. You can find the full proposal at: http://www.ripe.net/ripe/policies/proposals/2014-09 We encourage you to review this proposal and send your comments to <address-policy-wg(a)ripe.net> before 21 November 2014. Regards, Marco Schmidt Policy Development Officer RIPE NCC

1 0