Exuse me about two same emails. It was bag in my client 2015-05-11 23:22 GMT+03:00, Sergey Stecenko <stecenkoserj@gmail.com>:
Hi all!
I don't understand true reasons of this proposal creation.
Let's think together. If it was created to interrupt exhaustion of IPv4 blocks, I want retort: today, 11.05.2015 have been allocated 6392 IPv4 from last /8 (last block is 185.99.220.0/22, 256/4=64, 64*99=6336, 6336+224/4=6392)
If we go here https://www.ripe.net/manage-ips-and-asns/resource-transfers-and-mergers/ipv4... press ctrl+F and input 185. we can see 508 results, but we should devide it by 2, due to there are 2 results in one transfer. So there are 254 transfers of IPv4 from the last /8. It is 4% from all allocated IPv4 /8.
Also you should draw your attention to some LIRs who make more than 10 transfers every day. Yes, they don't transfer IPs from last /8. But did you think how many resources RIPE can fill if it returns unused resources? May be we will think globaly but don't about how to close a hole doesn't affect IPv4 exhaustion.
So I oppose this proposal.
2015-05-11 22:44 GMT+03:00, Sascha Luck [ml] <apwg@c4inet.net>:
On Mon, May 11, 2015 at 09:32:19PM +0200, Radu-Adrian FEURDEAN wrote:
This is borderline to bad faith.
ISTR you not being very happy about being accused on this list, so I would thank you very much, indeed, not to accuse me of acting in bad faith.
Yours sincerely, Sascha Luck
-- ----- Kind regards, Sergey Stecenko
-- ----- Kind regards, Sergey Stecenko