Re: [address-policy-wg] 2010-01 New Policy Proposal (Temporary Internet Number Assignment Policies)

"Following the conclusion of the experiment the results must be published free of charge and free from disclosure constraints."

there is a gap between conclusion of an experiment and publication of an academic paper where the researcher(s) does not wish to disclose.

Would the goals of this proposal not be better set by creating a collection of temporary objects under a dedicated LIR that is clearly marked as such that are 'loaned' to organisations using them rather than creating a new class of registrations in the RIR?

sometimes one wants 'unknown' space, i.e. space not known being used for research. or one wants 'new' space, i.e. testing bogon filters. randy