Hi all, I did not comment on this proposal earlier, as I had nothing to amend. I support this policy exactly as it has been proposed. Please accept and implement it. Further adjustments and clarifications (regarding end-sites etc) we can do afterwards, in smaller increments. Thanks and all the best, Matthias Fetzer On 11/14/24 08:38, Tobias Fiebig via address-policy-wg wrote:
Moin,
TL;DR: If you: - Support the proposal; OR - Are ok with the proposal/see no issue in moving it forward; OR - Can live with the proposal if thereafter a thorough cleanup effort of the whole policy starts, please speak up now. -------------
The extended discussion phase of 2024-01 is drawing closer to its end.
After the presentation at the last meeting there was a lot of positive feedback, and a couple of people promised to write on the mailinglist (which, contrary to offline comments, counts).
The major comment during the session was Gert noting that the proposal uses a lot of text. My counter point was that the grown policy we currently have necessitates that amount of text to account for all the corner cases and (excuse my German) 'Sonderlocken' we created over the decades.
My point on that is that fixing this needs a more comprehensive revision of the policy foundation, which will take us several years;
My suggestion is: - Implement 2024-01 - Start working on the more fundamental clean-up thereafter, as this will take long
In any case, I do need some feedback from you; Otherwise, this will not be able to move in any direction.
With best regards, Tobias