* "Radu-Adrian FEURDEAN" <ripe-wgs@radu-adrian.feurdean.net>
1. Separate pools or single pool a. have a "last /8 pool" which is 185.0.0.0/8 (strictly one /22 per LIR) and a "recovered space pool" containing all space received from IANA as "recovered and redistributed space" (for extra allocations) - APNIC-like separation of pools b. treat all addressing space available for allocation as a single pool
B. KISS.
2. Conditions for allocation the first /22. - none (keep the situation as it is today - our preferred option) - something else (please detail)
Maintain the status quo.
3. Further allocation(s) (after the first /22) 3.1 introduce some minimum delay after the last allocation : 12 months (Elvis' favourite) ? 18 Months ? 24 Months (my favourite) ? More ? Less ? None ? 3.1.1 Does that mean one can get a new allocation every X months (LACNIC-style) while the stock lasts ? 3.2 Allocation size : /22 ? /23 ? variable depending on how much is available at the time of allocation, max /22, min /24 (which does imply a little more policy text in order to detail this) ? 3.3 Additional conditions 3.3.1 "LIR did not perform an outbound transfer" (do you think it would make sense to have this condition for the first allocation too) ? 3.3.2 Other conditions ???
None of the above. My preference is to maintain the status quo - no additional allocations. I do not quite see why we should change the «last /8» policy which in my view has been quite successful (except for the abuse that 2015-01 hopefully helps shut down). If it ain't broke, don't fix it? Unless we interpret «broke» to mean «exhausted». If so, c'est la vie. Tore