Hi Nick, On 10/3/15 16:36, Nick Hilliard wrote:
thanks to Tore for pointing this out, but page 6 of:
http://www.apnic.net/__data/assets/pdf_file/0011/80786/apnic-ec-minutes-2014...
contains the following:
21. Inter-RIR transfer policy discussion
The EC considered the Inter-RIR transfer policy discussions (attached).
The EC unanimously resolved to place a temporary moratorium on inter RIR transfer with RIPE NCC, pending discussions and confirmation with APNIC, ARIN and RIPE communities that such transfers will not change APNIC’s status as sharing reciprocal, compatible, needs-based policy with ARIN.
Motion proposed by Paul Wilson, seconded by Akinori Maemura.
Could someone from APNIC, ARIN or both explain the background to this decision?
While I cannot answer on behalf of the other RIRs, we have given an update about the inter-RIR transfer policy proposal last week, during APNIC 39. I hope the video and transcripts will provide you with the clarification requested (please see session Policy SIG-3) https://2015.apricot.net/program#agenda/day10 Best regards, Andrea Cima RIPE NCC
I haven't seen any discussions in the RIPE community about this, and without knowing the background it seems peculiar that APNIC feels it necessary to consult ARIN about APNIC->RIPE NCC resource transfers.
Nick