Hi Ronald, The RIPE NCC does not disclose non-public information on a voluntary basis. We are unable to share this with the working group. Kind regards Ingrid Wijte On 18/08/2016 23:57, Ronald F. Guilmette wrote:
Ms. Wijte,
Thanks so much for your further reply. I think that I have just one last question...
In message <8cf746fe-be8a-4782-8213-7ce7d01d6908@ripe.net>, Ingrid Wijte <ingrid@ripe.net> wrote:
We can confirm that of these seven terminations {2015/2016}, none involved members who were natural persons. OK. Good. That's what I suspected might be the case.
In accordance with article 9.5 of the Standard Service Agreement, when a membership is terminated we cease providing any RIPE NCC services and begin the deregistration procedure according to section B. of “Closure of Members, Deregistration of Internet Resources and Legacy Internet Resources”. Once the resources have been deregistered, we have no further contact or relationship with them and neither party has any ongoing duty to the other*. OK. Good. That's what I suspected might be the case.
So, given that (a) none of the seven RIPE NCC members who were terminated for non-financial reasons in 2015 & 2016 (a) were "natural persons", also also (b) that RIPE NCC owes -no- ongoing duty of care to any of these seven terminated member entities, would it be possible for RIPE NCC to release, e.g to the Anti-Abuse Working Group, copies of the various bona fide documents relating to just these seven non-financially-terminated former members, e.g. so that members of the Anti-Abuse Working Group could study them, e.g. to look for patterns which might help to reduce future problems and incidents of the kind(s) that were caused by these seven former (and now terminated) members?
Regards, rfg