Re: [anti-abuse-wg] Fwd: Re: RBL policy
no not all dnsbls are a problem. none of the other ones block non-directly related prefixes as a means of extortion into complete breach of contract. there are some 110 of them last time we checked. we only were on the 2 operated by spamhaus. :P so by far... pretty much all dnsbl's list the ips that originate the 'undesired' traffic, which stops it from reaching those that use their service, and that's where it ends for them... that's perfectly acceptable. (as long as it's the actual end user making the decision to use their 'filtering' or not) howeverrrrr... then there is spamhaus... which goes 'oh on 1.2.3.4 is a website of which the url was mentioned in some UCE', let's list 1.2.3.4 and demand complete disconnection at the isp, if they don't do it we list 1.2.3.0/24, if they still don't cooperate with us we'll run some traceroutes and sh ip bgps and see who suppliers their isp with most of their transit and list their networks as well. (and -those- usually -do- use smtp ;) as for 194.109/16. that ain't ours. lol. you didn't actually think i was gonna disclose OUR front operations' prefixes to spamhaus again right? lol. (plus you'll be hard pushed to find an smtp server on any of those anyway - it's obsolete...;) as for the ripe mailinglist being smtp... yes. it unfortunately still is.. and it's about the ONLY thing that still needs smtp, next to signing up to habbo hotel. lol. i haven't started the mail client for anything else in years. lol. face it: smtp is dead, the reason it is dead: is spamhaus itself. making it unreliable. mainly. On 30 ينا, 2017 م 12:52, ox wrote:
On Mon, 30 Jan 2017 12:30:13 +0000 HRH Prince Sven Olaf von CyberBunker <svenk@xs4all.nl> wrote:
now, please take your shitty nagging about 'abuse' of your crappy silly old smtp protocol, which doesn't even -originate- from our networks in the first fucking place, and stick it where the sun doesn't shine... as for malware... windows is the malware there... it <snip snip>
You are obviously an intelligent person and I am sure you have a lot to contribute to an emailing list discussing abuse involving smtp where you have subscribed using smtp, etc etc.
What would really help (instead of simply /dev/null) would be some type of structure to your rantings as some of it seems actually valuable and important but it is mixed in with so much bullshit that it is too much work and effort to separate the shit from the gold.
Is your problem with RBL's in general? - Are you saying that all DNSBL is evil? or just Spamhaus? You obviously have not nulled all 25 - as poc of your 194.109.24.25:25 is well functional :)
Also, maybe for clarity - Not all DNSBL uses pre emtive blocking, as we established Simon Forster said that "All DNSBL are not the same"
Sorry to be asking something which you may already have said in your long rants somewhere, just that it will take too long to read all the crap you wrote - easier to just ask :)
Andre
On Mon, 30 Jan 2017 13:01:46 +0000 HRH Prince Sven Olaf von CyberBunker <svenk@xs4all.nl> wrote:
no not all dnsbls are a problem. none of the other ones block non-directly related prefixes as a means of extortion into complete breach of contract. there are some 110 of them last time we checked. we only were on the 2 operated by spamhaus. :P so by far... pretty much all dnsbl's list the ips that originate the 'undesired' traffic, which stops it from reaching those that use their service, and that's where it ends for them... that's perfectly acceptable. (as long as it's the actual end user making the decision to use their 'filtering' or not)
Okay, got it, thank you for that
howeverrrrr... then there is spamhaus...
yeah, but it will show good manners if you make a new thread about that?
as for the ripe mailinglist being smtp... yes. it unfortunately still is.. and it's about the ONLY thing that still needs smtp, next to signing up to habbo hotel. lol. i haven't started the mail client for anything else in years. lol. face it: smtp is dead, the reason it is dead: is spamhaus itself. making it unreliable. mainly.
we will have to agree to disagree (or not agree - with the same result :) ) smtp - 2017 my pov (and own stats) There has never been so much legit traffic sent ever... Easy to check though as everyone on here has their own stats and to quickly analize 25 vs say 80 (wow - and 443 is just as crazy in terms of growth as 25!) in 2015 as compared to 2016 - smtp is alive and kicking (so is 443!) Andre
participants (2)
-
HRH Prince Sven Olaf von CyberBunker
-
ox