Hi all,
One comment I did make was that it was paradoxical, on one hand, to
bemoan the depeering of large network(s) from route servers and discuss
how IXPs could engage to bring them back while, on the other hand,
trying to implement a practice which would dictate how and where they
should register their routing objects.
And this will definitely won't help to bring them back (and probably nothing will but we can try ... )
As I mentioned in my previous email, as stated in the MARNS for CDN/Cloud providers their approach for the same problem is different and possibly incompatible.
In a perfect world where all RIR support and have the same APIs to manage IRR objects, this could have an opportunity, but in the current state of affairs for IRR management in RIRs, I think it is difficult.