Fwd: [NRO-IANAXFER] Internet Number Community IANA Stewardship Proposal: Final Call for Comments
Dear colleagues, Today the Consolidated RIR IANA Stewardship Proposal (CRISP) team publishes the second draft of the Internet numbers community proposal on the transition of the IANA stewardship. This is intended as a final call for community feedback ahead of the submitting the finalised proposal to the IANA Stewardship Transition Coordination Group (ICG) on Thursday, 15 January. We understand that many in the RIPE community have a strong interest in this process, and feedback provided in this working group and elsewhere has been crucial in reaching the current draft. While there is still an opportunity to provide comments on the current text, we would also like to strongly encourage RIPE community members in favour of this proposal to express their support on this list or via the ianaxfer@nro.net mailing list. A quantifiable level of community support may be important in strengthening the Internet numbers community’s position later in the IANA stewardship transition process. As previously, the timeline for responding is quite tight, with a deadline of Monday, 12 January, for all comments. Best regards, Nurani Nimpuno on behalf of the RIPE CRISP team Begin forwarded message:
From: Izumi Okutani <izumi@nic.ad.jp> Subject: [NRO-IANAXFER] Internet Number Community IANA Stewardship Proposal: Final Call for Comments Date: 8 januari 2015 17:21:08 CET To: "ianaxfer@nro.net" <ianaxfer@nro.net>
Dear colleagues,
Please find the second draft of the Internet numbers community's response to the Request For Proposals issued by the IANA Stewardship Coordination Group (ICG).
This draft has been prepared by the Consolidated RIR IANA Stewardship Proposal (CRISP) Team, with considerations of feedback received from the global community on <ianaxfer@nro.net> mailing list.
We have incorporated the following key points in the second draft:
- Additional description on contract details, review committee and intellectual property rights - Description revised on Section V. NITA Requirements and VI. Community Process for more clarity - No changes are made to key elements of the proposal
The CRISP Team have considered all comments expressed on <ianaxfer@nro.net> mailing list before the deadline of 5th Jan 2015, and would now like to make the final call for comments from the global community on the draft proposal, before submitting to the ICG.
Second Draft proposal: ------------------------ Clean Version : <http://www.nro.net/crisp-proposal-second-draft>
Redline Version: <http:/www.nro.net/crisp-proposal-second-draft-change-control>
The deadline for providing feedback: Mon, 12 January 2015 23:59 UTC Feedback should be sent to : <ianaxfer@nro.net> mailing list
Community Inputs Considered by the CRISP Team: ------------------------------------------ You can check the status of the issues raised by the community and proposed the CRISP Team positions at:
<http://www.nro.net/crisp-iana-xfer-summary-discussion-08012015>
Key dates: ----------- Second draft to be published : 8 Jan 2015 Second draft comments close : 12 Jan 2015, 23:59 UTC Final proposal to be sent to ICG : 15 Jan 2015
How to Engage in Discussions: ----------------------------- All global discussions, for the CRISP team to consider as community feedback, will be conducted at <ianaxfer@nro.net> mailing list. All the CRISP Team discussions are open to observers.
Next Step: ----------- In developing the final draft based on further feedback, the CRISP Team will ensure it has completed considerations of all substantial issues raised by the global community, which are compiled in the published issues list. The proposal will only incorporate issues that the CRISP team believes have received consensus support from the community.
References: ------------ * Discussions by the CRISP Team Details of all the CRISP team's work to date, including recordings, minutes and agendas of all the CRISP Team teleconferences and a public archive of the internal CRISP team mailing list, are available at: https://nro.net/crisp-team
* Other links: - The ICG request for proposals: <https://www.icann.org/news/announcement-3-2014-09-03-en>
- The IANA Stewardship Transition Discussion in each RIR region: <http://www.nro.net/timeline-engagement>
- First Draft proposal (Edited version) <http://www.nro.net/crisp-proposal-first-draft-1-1>
_______________________________________________ ianaxfer mailing list ianaxfer@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/ianaxfer
At Thu, 8 Jan 2015 17:27:53 +0100, Nurani Nimpuno wrote:
Dear colleagues,
Today the Consolidated RIR IANA Stewardship Proposal (CRISP) team publishes the second draft of the Internet numbers community proposal on the transition of the IANA stewardship.
I have reviewed the "redline" PDF version of this draft, and attach a signature covering this file, made with my PGP key (ID AE995ED9), so as to remove any doubt as to which version of the document I have reviewed. This draft of the proposal seems to me to say what is needed as input from the number-resources community to the process of transition of the contract for the IANA function, proposing - to keep operational processes undisturbed, - to transfer the contracting-party role from NTIA to the RIRs co-ordinated through the NRO, - to keep number-resource data in the public domain, and - to vest other IANA-related intellectual property in a safe place; and explaining very clearly - how the RIR processes have been developed, - how these processes work, and - how these processes have been used to prepare the current proposal. Congratulations and thanks to the CRISP Team for such a thorough job, done at a time of the year when so many of us were enjoying a break. Good job! I shall communicate a number of editorial suggestions ("nits") directly to the CRISP team. Best regards, Niall O'Reilly
Nurani, Thanks to all who contributed to this document. I have been following the updates over the last month and have read through the proposal; it looks like a sound basis in terms of ensuring long term stability of global Internet number resources. Particular thanks to the RIR community members who were involved in drafting the proposal. It has also been very helpful to get regular updates to the RIPE Co-operation Working Group, as it reaffirms CRISP's community-centred approach to the the IANA transfer program. A couple of questions: 1. has the IETF Trust agreed in principal to accept IPR transfer of the IANA trademark and iana.org domain? 2. Re: III.A.4.ix, the IETF Trust is not "public domain" so it may be appropriate to use a different phrase in this paragraph, e.g. "to the community via an appropriate holding mechanism as described in section III.A.2", or something along those lines. 3. which jurisdiction / governing law will be used for the proposed new IANA contract between the RIRs and ICANN? The State of California / US Federal law? or will this be left for a future discussion? 4. III.A.4.x: resolution of disputes should first use arbitration (although it may be difficult to get an appropriate arbiter), and then through the legal system. Overall, this looks like an excellent document and I fully support it. Kind regards, Nick Hilliard Chief Technical Officer http://www.inex.ie/ INEX - Internet Neutral Exchange Association Citywest Business Campus, Dublin 24 Ireland On 08/01/2015 16:27, Nurani Nimpuno wrote:
Dear colleagues,
Today the Consolidated RIR IANA Stewardship Proposal (CRISP) team publishes the second draft of the Internet numbers community proposal on the transition of the IANA stewardship. This is intended as a final call for community feedback ahead of the submitting the finalised proposal to the IANA Stewardship Transition Coordination Group (ICG) on Thursday, 15 January.
We understand that many in the RIPE community have a strong interest in this process, and feedback provided in this working group and elsewhere has been crucial in reaching the current draft.
While there is still an opportunity to provide comments on the current text, we would also like to strongly encourage RIPE community members in favour of this proposal to express their support on this list or via the ianaxfer@nro.net mailing list. A quantifiable level of community support may be important in strengthening the Internet numbers community’s position later in the IANA stewardship transition process.
As previously, the timeline for responding is quite tight, with a deadline of Monday, 12 January, for all comments.
Best regards,
Nurani Nimpuno on behalf of the RIPE CRISP team
Begin forwarded message:
From: Izumi Okutani <izumi@nic.ad.jp> Subject: [NRO-IANAXFER] Internet Number Community IANA Stewardship Proposal: Final Call for Comments Date: 8 januari 2015 17:21:08 CET To: "ianaxfer@nro.net" <ianaxfer@nro.net>
Dear colleagues,
Please find the second draft of the Internet numbers community's response to the Request For Proposals issued by the IANA Stewardship Coordination Group (ICG).
This draft has been prepared by the Consolidated RIR IANA Stewardship Proposal (CRISP) Team, with considerations of feedback received from the global community on <ianaxfer@nro.net> mailing list.
We have incorporated the following key points in the second draft:
- Additional description on contract details, review committee and intellectual property rights - Description revised on Section V. NITA Requirements and VI. Community Process for more clarity - No changes are made to key elements of the proposal
The CRISP Team have considered all comments expressed on <ianaxfer@nro.net> mailing list before the deadline of 5th Jan 2015, and would now like to make the final call for comments from the global community on the draft proposal, before submitting to the ICG.
Second Draft proposal: ------------------------ Clean Version : <http://www.nro.net/crisp-proposal-second-draft>
Redline Version: <http:/www.nro.net/crisp-proposal-second-draft-change-control>
The deadline for providing feedback: Mon, 12 January 2015 23:59 UTC Feedback should be sent to : <ianaxfer@nro.net> mailing list
Community Inputs Considered by the CRISP Team: ------------------------------------------ You can check the status of the issues raised by the community and proposed the CRISP Team positions at:
<http://www.nro.net/crisp-iana-xfer-summary-discussion-08012015>
Key dates: ----------- Second draft to be published : 8 Jan 2015 Second draft comments close : 12 Jan 2015, 23:59 UTC Final proposal to be sent to ICG : 15 Jan 2015
How to Engage in Discussions: ----------------------------- All global discussions, for the CRISP team to consider as community feedback, will be conducted at <ianaxfer@nro.net> mailing list. All the CRISP Team discussions are open to observers.
Next Step: ----------- In developing the final draft based on further feedback, the CRISP Team will ensure it has completed considerations of all substantial issues raised by the global community, which are compiled in the published issues list. The proposal will only incorporate issues that the CRISP team believes have received consensus support from the community.
References: ------------ * Discussions by the CRISP Team Details of all the CRISP team's work to date, including recordings, minutes and agendas of all the CRISP Team teleconferences and a public archive of the internal CRISP team mailing list, are available at: https://nro.net/crisp-team
* Other links: - The ICG request for proposals: <https://www.icann.org/news/announcement-3-2014-09-03-en>
- The IANA Stewardship Transition Discussion in each RIR region: <http://www.nro.net/timeline-engagement>
- First Draft proposal (Edited version) <http://www.nro.net/crisp-proposal-first-draft-1-1>
_______________________________________________ ianaxfer mailing list ianaxfer@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/ianaxfer
Please see below.
-----Original Message----- From: cooperation-wg [mailto:cooperation-wg-bounces@ripe.net]On Behalf Of Nick Hilliard Sent: lundi, 12. janvier 2015 00:55 To: Nurani Nimpuno; RIPE Cooperation Working Group Subject: Re: [cooperation-wg] Fwd: [NRO-IANAXFER] Internet Number Community IANA Stewardship Proposal: Final Call for Comments
SNIP
4. III.A.4.x: resolution of disputes should first use arbitration (although it may be difficult to get an appropriate arbiter), and then through the legal system.
Arbitration is an alternative to national courts. That is, if an arbitration clause is included, then the dispute will not go through the regular court system (unless the validity of the arbitation is challenged, or there are issues enforcing the arbitration award). Best, Richard
Overall, this looks like an excellent document and I fully support it.
Kind regards, Nick Hilliard Chief Technical Officer
http://www.inex.ie/ INEX - Internet Neutral Exchange Association Citywest Business Campus, Dublin 24 Ireland
Dear colleagues,
Today the Consolidated RIR IANA Stewardship Proposal (CRISP) team publishes the second draft of the Internet numbers community
On 08/01/2015 16:27, Nurani Nimpuno wrote: proposal on the transition of the IANA stewardship. This is intended as a final call for community feedback ahead of the submitting the finalised proposal to the IANA Stewardship Transition Coordination Group (ICG) on Thursday, 15 January.
We understand that many in the RIPE community have a strong
interest in this process, and feedback provided in this working group and elsewhere has been crucial in reaching the current draft.
While there is still an opportunity to provide comments on the
current text, we would also like to strongly encourage RIPE community members in favour of this proposal to express their support on this list or via the ianaxfer@nro.net mailing list. A quantifiable level of community support may be important in strengthening the Internet numbers community’s position later in the IANA stewardship transition process.
As previously, the timeline for responding is quite tight, with
a deadline of Monday, 12 January, for all comments.
Best regards,
Nurani Nimpuno on behalf of the RIPE CRISP team
Begin forwarded message:
From: Izumi Okutani <izumi@nic.ad.jp> Subject: [NRO-IANAXFER] Internet Number Community IANA
Stewardship Proposal: Final Call for Comments
Date: 8 januari 2015 17:21:08 CET To: "ianaxfer@nro.net" <ianaxfer@nro.net>
Dear colleagues,
Please find the second draft of the Internet numbers community's response to the Request For Proposals issued by the IANA Stewardship Coordination Group (ICG).
This draft has been prepared by the Consolidated RIR IANA Stewardship Proposal (CRISP) Team, with considerations of feedback received from the global community on <ianaxfer@nro.net> mailing list.
We have incorporated the following key points in the second draft:
- Additional description on contract details, review committee and intellectual property rights - Description revised on Section V. NITA Requirements and VI. Community Process for more clarity - No changes are made to key elements of the proposal
The CRISP Team have considered all comments expressed on <ianaxfer@nro.net> mailing list before the deadline of 5th Jan 2015, and would now like to make the final call for comments from the global community on the draft proposal, before submitting to the ICG.
Second Draft proposal: ------------------------ Clean Version : <http://www.nro.net/crisp-proposal-second-draft>
Redline Version: <http:/www.nro.net/crisp-proposal-second-draft-change-control>
The deadline for providing feedback: Mon, 12 January 2015 23:59 UTC Feedback should be sent to : <ianaxfer@nro.net> mailing list
Community Inputs Considered by the CRISP Team: ------------------------------------------ You can check the status of the issues raised by the community and proposed the CRISP Team positions at:
<http://www.nro.net/crisp-iana-xfer-summary-discussion-08012015>
Key dates: ----------- Second draft to be published : 8 Jan 2015 Second draft comments close : 12 Jan 2015, 23:59 UTC Final proposal to be sent to ICG : 15 Jan 2015
How to Engage in Discussions: ----------------------------- All global discussions, for the CRISP team to consider as community feedback, will be conducted at <ianaxfer@nro.net> mailing list. All the CRISP Team discussions are open to observers.
Next Step: ----------- In developing the final draft based on further feedback, the CRISP Team will ensure it has completed considerations of all substantial issues raised by the global community, which are compiled in the published issues list. The proposal will only incorporate issues that the CRISP team believes have received consensus support from the community.
References: ------------ * Discussions by the CRISP Team Details of all the CRISP team's work to date, including recordings, minutes and agendas of all the CRISP Team teleconferences and a public archive of the internal CRISP team mailing list, are available at: https://nro.net/crisp-team
* Other links: - The ICG request for proposals: <https://www.icann.org/news/announcement-3-2014-09-03-en>
- The IANA Stewardship Transition Discussion in each RIR region: <http://www.nro.net/timeline-engagement>
- First Draft proposal (Edited version) <http://www.nro.net/crisp-proposal-first-draft-1-1>
_______________________________________________ ianaxfer mailing list ianaxfer@nro.net https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/ianaxfer
participants (4)
-
Niall O'Reilly -
Nick Hilliard -
Nurani Nimpuno -
Richard Hill