October 2002 - db-wg - mailman.ripe.net

<auto-dbm@ripe.net> is slow this afternoon.
by RIPE Database Administration 17 May '18

17 May '18

Dear Colleagues, Because of a very high level of use this afternoon, the response time of <auto-dbm(a)ripe.net> is longer than normal. I have made contact with those who are responsible and I expect the situation to improve as the machine works through the queue. Please be patient. Obviously we at the RIPE NCC Database Group are continuously working to make the performance of the database as good as possible. However, we cannot make improvements in zero time. We thank you for your co-operation up to now and we ask for your continued co-operation so that everyone receives the best possible service. If you have anymore questions, please contact <ripe-dbm(a)ripe.net>. Regards, Ambrose Magee ____________________________ RIPE Database Administration.

2 2

Hierarchical authorisation failed, request forwarded to maintaine r ???
by Marcus.Ruchti＠colt.de 05 Nov '02

05 Nov '02

Hi all, can somebody tell me why this update failed? inet-num maintainer is NONE and AS maintainer is ours ! This is an ARIN /16 network, but the /22 part of it is announced in the RIPE region.. thanks for your help!! Marcus Ruchti New FAILED: [route] 143.58.120.0/22 Hierarchical authorisation failed, request forwarded to maintainer. route: 143.58.120.0/22 descr: MAYER, BROWN, ROWE & MAW GAEDERTZ descr: ***routed per request*** origin: AS8220 mnt-by: DE-COLT-MNT changed: markb(a)de.colt.net 20020813 source: RIPE inetnum: 0.0.0.0 - 255.255.255.255 netname: IANA-BLK descr: The whole IPv4 address space country: NL admin-c: IANA1-RIPE tech-c: IANA1-RIPE status: ALLOCATED UNSPECIFIED remarks: The country is really worldwide. remarks: This address space is assigned at various other places in remarks: the world and might therefore not be in the RIPE database. mnt-by: RIPE-NCC-HM-MNT mnt-lower: RIPE-NCC-HM-MNT mnt-routes: RIPE-NCC-NONE-MNT changed: bitbucket(a)ripe.net 20010529 changed: bitbucket(a)ripe.net 20020625 source: RIPE route: 143.58.120.0/22 descr: MBRG-FFM origin: AS3320 mnt-by: DTAG-RR changed: mbt(a)nic.dtag.de 20020619 source: RIPE route: 143.58.120.0/23 descr: MBRG-FFM origin: AS8354 notify: info(a)twinwave.net mnt-by: TWINWAVE-MNT changed: g.cipollone(a)twinwave.net 20020417 source: RIPE role: Internet Assigned Numbers Authority address: see http://www.iana.org. e-mail: bitbucket(a)ripe.net admin-c: IANA1-RIPE tech-c: IANA1-RIPE nic-hdl: IANA1-RIPE remarks: For more information on IANA services remarks: go to IANA web site at http://www.iana.org. mnt-by: RIPE-NCC-MNT changed: bitbucket(a)ripe.net 20010411 source: RIPE Marcus Ruchti Internet Systemingenieur mailto:marcus.ruchti@colt.de COLT TELECOM GmbH Herriotstr. 4 D-60528 Frankfurt Fon: +49 (0) 69 / 5 66 06 - 6351 Fax: +49 (0) 69 / 5 66 06 - 6350

5 10

IRT object and authentication schemes
by Havard Eidnes 31 Oct '02

31 Oct '02

Hi, someone's prodded me wrt. the IRT object registration. This finally made me take a closer look at the available documentation defining this object type. I have one question (well, I may have more, but this one is the most important one, I think): In section 5 of http://www.ripe.net/ripe/docs/irt-object.html I find the following text: When adding a reference to an irt object the update of an inet[6]num should pass the following authorisation checks: * from the irt object itself as specified in one of the "auth:" attribute * from any of the mntner objects that protect the inet[6]num object (i.e. referenced using "mnt-by:" attribute). Is there a logical AND between these two items? (I think there is, but it really ought to be said explicitly, and the "should pass" phrase should be replaced by "must pass both of".) This is pretty crucial when evaluating what should be registered in the IRT object, as unwise choices (no overlap between irt auth: and mntnr auth:) on this front will at best make it very cumbersome to add IRT references to inetnum / inet6num objects, requiring nested signatures (I wonder, does the RIPE DB support that?). Oh, yes, I also think the IRT definition document needs to say a few words about what specific roles the admin-c and tech-c of an IRT object is supposed to fill. Regards, - Håvard

2 1

Summary of ERX-TF discussion
by leo vegoda 30 Oct '02

30 Oct '02

Dear Colleagues, As promised, here is a summary of the short discussion had on the <erx-tf(a)ripe.net> mailing list over the last few weeks. There have been about 15 messages in total. On 10 October we published the RIPE NCC's proposed ERX process for IPv4 to the Task Force. There were two technical queries: a request for confirmation that all contacts in both databases be e-mailed. Also, there was a request for confirmation on how reverse delegations would be handled. Substantive issues included a question on how early registrations would be handled from a policy point of view. The RIPE NCC confirmed that in the past, the majority of registrants have agreed to meet the current policy requirements for registration. However, we also noted that previous registrations have tended to be done for organisations who place a value on registration data. It was argued that the policy issues were less important than the accuracy of the registration data transferred/updated. No other issues on the transfer process were raised. It appears that the Task Force is happy with the proposed transfer process. As such, we would like to publish the proposed process in the next few days. Regards, -- leo vegoda RIPE NCC Registration Services

1 0

Improved Query Processing on RIPE Database Serve
by RIPE Database Administration 24 Oct '02

24 Oct '02

[ Apologies for multiple copies. ] Colleagues, Whois query processing for the RIPE Database Server has been revised to be more consistent and helpful to users. In the past, the server would make a number of changes to the user query without telling the user, for example removing characters that it did not understand or truncating the query. The new implementation will perform exactly the query the user requested, if possible, and give errors when not. Warnings are now returned where appropriate. A full description of the changes may be found here: http://www.ripe.net/db/whois-query-2002.html In general, all correct queries will provide exactly the same results as on the previous version of the server. If you have any questions please send them to <ripe-dbm(a)ripe.net>. Suggestions may be sent to <ripe-dbm(a)ripe.net>, or discussed on the RIPE Database working group mailing list, details of which may be found here: http://www.ripe.net/ripe/wg/db/index.html -- Shane Kerr RIPE NCC

1 0

[Ted.Hardie@nominum.com: [Ietf-not43] Working Group Last Call: draft-ietf-crisp-requirements-01.txt]
by Stephane Bortzmeyer 16 Oct '02

16 Oct '02

This is also for address registries like RIPE-NCC so I believe everybody should read this post-whois document and comment before the Atlanta meeting.

1 0

RE: FAILED update.
by Pieterjan d'Hertog 14 Oct '02

14 Oct '02

> > -----Mensaje original----- > > De: Iglesias Fuente, Jesus > > Enviado el: viernes 11 de octubre de 2002 13:09 > > Para: 'auto-rpsl(a)ripe.net' > > Asunto: longack > > > > password: 7djsfy25ddn > > Please change your update password :-) --- Pieterjan d'Hertog, Senior Network Engineer Belgacom Skynet NV/SA, 2 Rue Carli, B-1140 Brussels Phone +3227061311 Fax +3227061150 http://www.skynet.be PGP fingerprint: D9AB CD6A 2A78 73CC 68BF 0AFA 8FB3 5821 E4BB 9D2E

1 0

Re: NCC#2002102136 RV: FAILED update.
by RIPE Database Administration 14 Oct '02

14 Oct '02

Dear Jesus Iglesias, [Please send any operational problems/doubts with the RIPE database to ripe-dbm(a)ripe.net , this is the best address to have your doubts answered]. The failure of your update is related to the fact that you have sent your object quoted: > as-set: AS-BTTEL > descr: BT Telecomunicaciones customers > members: AS8903 > ... Please don't quote the objects, ie send like as-set: AS-BTTEL descr: BT Telecomunicaciones customers members: AS8903 ... Also, we recommend never to send your password in the clean in mail messages, especially to public mailing lists. If you have any more questions, please contact <ripe-dbm(a)ripe.net>. Regards, Tiago Antao ____________________________ RIPE Database Administration. Original message follows: ------------------------ > Hello, > Can anyone tell me why did this update fail? > The robot answered: > > Update FAILED: Syntax error in object > ***Error: Error with class attribute, class invalid > > Thanks for your help ! > Regards. > > _________________________________ > Jes�s Iglesias Fuente > IP Platforms & Services (Planning) > BT Ignite Spain > jesus.iglesias(a)ignite.com > Phone: (+34) 91.270.62.14 > Fax: (+34) 91.270.63.10 > _____________________________________________ > > > -----Mensaje original----- > De: Iglesias Fuente, Jesus > Enviado el: viernes 11 de octubre de 2002 13:09 > Para: 'auto-rpsl(a)ripe.net' > Asunto: longack > > password: *********************** > > as-set: AS-BTTEL > descr: BT Telecomunicaciones customers > members: AS8903 > members: AS3324, AS21025 > members: AS12334, AS20784 > members: AS12356, AS12636 > members: AS8239, AS12430 > members: AS12845, AS21268 > members: AS9192, AS13066 > members: AS13143, AS15734 > members: AS12946, AS15369 > members: AS15912, AS15937 > members: AS15963, AS16373 > members: AS16203, AS13205 > members: AS20815, AS20944 > members: AS16371, AS21368 > members: AS21193, AS20718 > members: AS20760, AS20607 > members: AS24830, AS21181 > members: AS15919, AS25267 > remarks: BT Telecomunicaciones customers ASs > tech-c: BTT2-RIPE > admin-c: EL729-RIPE > notify: opsingguar(a)bt.es > mnt-by: BTTEL-MNT > changed: jesus.iglesias(a)bt.es > source: RIPE > > > aut-num: AS8903 > as-name: BT > descr: BT Tel AS 1 > import: from AS701 action pref=100; accept ANY > import: from AS5400 action pref=100; accept ANY > import: from AS3561 action pref=100; accept ANY > import: from AS2856 action pref=100; accept ANY > import: from AS6895 action pref=100; accept AS6895 > import: from AS3262 action pref=100; accept AS3262 > import: from AS8761 action pref=100; accept AS8761 > import: from AS8782 action pref=100; accept AS8782 > import: from AS8220 action pref=100; accept AS8220 > import: from AS4589 action pref=100; accept AS4589 > import: from AS12457 action pref=100; accept AS12457 > import: from AS12357 action pref=100; accept AS12357 > import: from AS6897 action pref=100; accept AS6897 > import: from AS12479 action pref=100; accept AS12479 > import: from AS12852 action pref=100; accept AS12852 > import: from AS2686 action pref=100; accept AS2686 > import: from AS3352 action pref=100; accept AS3352 > import: from AS3324 action pref=100; accept AS3324 > import: from AS2134 action pref=100; accept AS2134 > import: from AS12359 action pref=100; accept AS12359 > import: from AS3352 action pref=100; accept AS3352 > import: from AS13041 action pref=100; accept AS13041 > import: from AS12386 action pref=100; accept AS12386 > import: from AS9019 action pref=100; accept AS9019 > import: from AS5978 action pref=100; accept AS5378 > import: from AS12482 action pref=100; accept AS12482 > import: from AS9106 action pref=100; accept AS9106 > import: from AS12715 action pref=100; accept AS12715 > import: from AS702 action pref=100; accept AS702 > import: from AS3247 action pref=100; accept AS-3247 > import: from AS766 action pref=100; accept AS-766 > import: from AS3257 action pref=100; accept AS-NACAMAR > import: from AS6669 action pref=100; accept AS-BTES > import: from AS3324 action pref=100; accept AS3324 > import: from AS12334 action pref=100; accept AS12334 > import: from AS12356 action pref=100; accept AS12356 > import: from AS8239 action pref=100; accept AS8239 > import: from AS12430 action pref=100; accept AS12430 > import: from AS12636 action pref=100; accept AS12636 > import: from AS12845 action pref=100; accept AS12845 > import: from AS12946 action pref=100; accept AS12946 > import: from AS9192 action pref=100; accept AS9192 > import: from AS13066 action pref=100; accept AS13066 > import: from AS13143 action pref=100; accept AS13143 > import: from AS15369 action pref=100; accept AS15369 > import: from AS15734 action pref=100; accept AS15734 > import: from AS15912 action pref=100; accept AS15912 > import: from AS15937 action pref=100; accept AS15937 > import: from AS15963 action pref=100; accept AS15963 > import: from AS16373 action pref=100; accept AS16373 > import: from AS16203 action pref=100; accept AS16203 > import: from AS13205 action pref=100; accept AS13205 > import: from AS21025 action pref=100; accept AS21025 > import: from AS20815 action pref=100; accept AS20815 > import: from AS20784 action pref=100; accept AS20784 > import: from AS20944 action pref=100; accept AS20944 > import: from AS16371 action pref=100; accept AS16371 > import: from AS21368 action pref=100; accept AS21368 > import: from AS21268 action pref=100; accept AS21268 > import: from AS21193 action pref=100; accept AS21193 > import: from AS20718 action pref=100; accept AS20718 > import: from AS20607 action pref=100; accept AS20607 > import: from AS20760 action pref=100; accept AS20760 > import: from AS24830 action pref=100; accept AS24830 > import: from AS21181 action pref=100; accept AS21181 > import: from AS15919 action pref=100; accept AS15919 > import: from AS25267 action pref=100; accept AS25267 > export: to AS701 announce AS-BTTEL > export: to AS5400 announce AS-BTTEL > export: to AS3561 announce AS-BTTEL > export: to AS2856 announce AS-BTTEL > export: to AS6669 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTTELESPANIX AS-BTTELCATNIX > export: to AS2134 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS2686 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS3262 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS3324 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS3352 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS6895 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS6897 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS8761 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS8220 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS4589 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12457 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12357 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12479 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12359 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS8782 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12852 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS13041 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12386 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS9019 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS8761 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12482 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS3262 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS9106 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12715 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS5378 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS3257 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS702 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS3247 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS766 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12334 announce ANY > export: to AS12356 announce ANY > export: to AS8239 announce ANY > export: to AS12430 announce ANY > export: to AS12636 announce ANY > export: to AS12845 announce ANY > export: to AS9192 announce ANY > export: to AS13066 announce ANY > export: to AS3324 announce ANY > export: to AS13143 announce ANY > export: to AS15734 announce ANY > export: to AS12946 announce ANY > export: to AS15369 announce ANY > export: to AS15912 announce ANY > export: to AS15937 announce ANY > export: to AS15963 announce ANY > export: to AS16373 announce ANY > export: to AS16203 announce ANY > export: to AS13205 announce ANY > export: to AS21025 announce ANY > export: to AS20815 announce ANY > export: to AS20784 announce ANY > export: to AS20944 announce ANY > export: to AS16371 announce ANY > export: to AS21368 announce ANY > export: to AS21268 announce ANY > export: to AS21193 announce ANY > export: to AS20718 announce ANY > export: to AS20607 announce ANY > export: to AS20760 announce ANY > export: to AS24830 announce ANY > export: to AS21181 announce ANY > export: to AS15919 announce ANY > export: to AS25267 announce ANY > admin-c: EL729-RIPE > tech-c: BTT2-RIPE > notify: opsingguar(a)bt.es > mnt-by: BTTEL-MNT > changed: jesus.iglesias(a)bt.es > source: RIPE > ********************************************** Noticia legal Este mensaje electr�nico contiene informaci�n de BT Ignite Espa�a S.A.U. que es privada y confidencial, siendo para el uso exclusivo de la persona (s) o entidades arriba mencionadas. Si usted no es el destinatario se�alado, le informamos que cualquier divulgaci�n, copia, distribuci�n o uso de los contenidos est� prohibida. Si usted ha recibido este mensaje por error, por favor borre su contenido lo antes posible. Gracias.

1 0

RE: RV: FAILED update.
by Wilfried Woeber, UniVie/ACOnet 14 Oct '02

14 Oct '02

> Hello, > Can anyone tell me why did this update fail? > The robot answered: > ... >********************************************** >Noticia legal >Este mensaje electrónico contiene información de BT Ignite España S.A.U. que >es privada y confidencial, siendo para el uso exclusivo de la persona (s) o >entidades arriba mencionadas. Si usted no es el destinatario señalado, le >informamos que cualquier divulgación, copia, distribución o uso de los >contenidos está prohibida. Si usted ha recibido este mensaje por error, por >favor borre su contenido lo antes posible. >Gracias. Sorry, I am not dealing with mails containing legal disclaimers or privacy restrictions (regardless of the language they are written in ;-) -WW

1 0

RV: FAILED update.
by jesus.iglesias＠bt.es 14 Oct '02

14 Oct '02

> Hello, > Can anyone tell me why did this update fail? > The robot answered: > > Update FAILED: Syntax error in object > ***Error: Error with class attribute, class invalid > > Thanks for your help ! > Regards. > > _________________________________ > Jesús Iglesias Fuente > IP Platforms & Services (Planning) > BT Ignite Spain > jesus.iglesias(a)ignite.com > Phone: (+34) 91.270.62.14 > Fax: (+34) 91.270.63.10 > _____________________________________________ > > > -----Mensaje original----- > De: Iglesias Fuente, Jesus > Enviado el: viernes 11 de octubre de 2002 13:09 > Para: 'auto-rpsl(a)ripe.net' > Asunto: longack > > password: 7djsfy25ddn > > as-set: AS-BTTEL > descr: BT Telecomunicaciones customers > members: AS8903 > members: AS3324, AS21025 > members: AS12334, AS20784 > members: AS12356, AS12636 > members: AS8239, AS12430 > members: AS12845, AS21268 > members: AS9192, AS13066 > members: AS13143, AS15734 > members: AS12946, AS15369 > members: AS15912, AS15937 > members: AS15963, AS16373 > members: AS16203, AS13205 > members: AS20815, AS20944 > members: AS16371, AS21368 > members: AS21193, AS20718 > members: AS20760, AS20607 > members: AS24830, AS21181 > members: AS15919, AS25267 > remarks: BT Telecomunicaciones customers ASs > tech-c: BTT2-RIPE > admin-c: EL729-RIPE > notify: opsingguar(a)bt.es > mnt-by: BTTEL-MNT > changed: jesus.iglesias(a)bt.es > source: RIPE > > > aut-num: AS8903 > as-name: BT > descr: BT Tel AS 1 > import: from AS701 action pref=100; accept ANY > import: from AS5400 action pref=100; accept ANY > import: from AS3561 action pref=100; accept ANY > import: from AS2856 action pref=100; accept ANY > import: from AS6895 action pref=100; accept AS6895 > import: from AS3262 action pref=100; accept AS3262 > import: from AS8761 action pref=100; accept AS8761 > import: from AS8782 action pref=100; accept AS8782 > import: from AS8220 action pref=100; accept AS8220 > import: from AS4589 action pref=100; accept AS4589 > import: from AS12457 action pref=100; accept AS12457 > import: from AS12357 action pref=100; accept AS12357 > import: from AS6897 action pref=100; accept AS6897 > import: from AS12479 action pref=100; accept AS12479 > import: from AS12852 action pref=100; accept AS12852 > import: from AS2686 action pref=100; accept AS2686 > import: from AS3352 action pref=100; accept AS3352 > import: from AS3324 action pref=100; accept AS3324 > import: from AS2134 action pref=100; accept AS2134 > import: from AS12359 action pref=100; accept AS12359 > import: from AS3352 action pref=100; accept AS3352 > import: from AS13041 action pref=100; accept AS13041 > import: from AS12386 action pref=100; accept AS12386 > import: from AS9019 action pref=100; accept AS9019 > import: from AS5978 action pref=100; accept AS5378 > import: from AS12482 action pref=100; accept AS12482 > import: from AS9106 action pref=100; accept AS9106 > import: from AS12715 action pref=100; accept AS12715 > import: from AS702 action pref=100; accept AS702 > import: from AS3247 action pref=100; accept AS-3247 > import: from AS766 action pref=100; accept AS-766 > import: from AS3257 action pref=100; accept AS-NACAMAR > import: from AS6669 action pref=100; accept AS-BTES > import: from AS3324 action pref=100; accept AS3324 > import: from AS12334 action pref=100; accept AS12334 > import: from AS12356 action pref=100; accept AS12356 > import: from AS8239 action pref=100; accept AS8239 > import: from AS12430 action pref=100; accept AS12430 > import: from AS12636 action pref=100; accept AS12636 > import: from AS12845 action pref=100; accept AS12845 > import: from AS12946 action pref=100; accept AS12946 > import: from AS9192 action pref=100; accept AS9192 > import: from AS13066 action pref=100; accept AS13066 > import: from AS13143 action pref=100; accept AS13143 > import: from AS15369 action pref=100; accept AS15369 > import: from AS15734 action pref=100; accept AS15734 > import: from AS15912 action pref=100; accept AS15912 > import: from AS15937 action pref=100; accept AS15937 > import: from AS15963 action pref=100; accept AS15963 > import: from AS16373 action pref=100; accept AS16373 > import: from AS16203 action pref=100; accept AS16203 > import: from AS13205 action pref=100; accept AS13205 > import: from AS21025 action pref=100; accept AS21025 > import: from AS20815 action pref=100; accept AS20815 > import: from AS20784 action pref=100; accept AS20784 > import: from AS20944 action pref=100; accept AS20944 > import: from AS16371 action pref=100; accept AS16371 > import: from AS21368 action pref=100; accept AS21368 > import: from AS21268 action pref=100; accept AS21268 > import: from AS21193 action pref=100; accept AS21193 > import: from AS20718 action pref=100; accept AS20718 > import: from AS20607 action pref=100; accept AS20607 > import: from AS20760 action pref=100; accept AS20760 > import: from AS24830 action pref=100; accept AS24830 > import: from AS21181 action pref=100; accept AS21181 > import: from AS15919 action pref=100; accept AS15919 > import: from AS25267 action pref=100; accept AS25267 > export: to AS701 announce AS-BTTEL > export: to AS5400 announce AS-BTTEL > export: to AS3561 announce AS-BTTEL > export: to AS2856 announce AS-BTTEL > export: to AS6669 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTTELESPANIX AS-BTTELCATNIX > export: to AS2134 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS2686 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS3262 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS3324 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS3352 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS6895 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS6897 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS8761 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS8220 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS4589 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12457 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12357 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12479 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12359 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS8782 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12852 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS13041 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12386 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS9019 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS8761 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12482 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS3262 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS9106 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12715 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS5378 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS3257 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS702 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS3247 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS766 announce AS-BTTEL AS-BTES > export: to AS12334 announce ANY > export: to AS12356 announce ANY > export: to AS8239 announce ANY > export: to AS12430 announce ANY > export: to AS12636 announce ANY > export: to AS12845 announce ANY > export: to AS9192 announce ANY > export: to AS13066 announce ANY > export: to AS3324 announce ANY > export: to AS13143 announce ANY > export: to AS15734 announce ANY > export: to AS12946 announce ANY > export: to AS15369 announce ANY > export: to AS15912 announce ANY > export: to AS15937 announce ANY > export: to AS15963 announce ANY > export: to AS16373 announce ANY > export: to AS16203 announce ANY > export: to AS13205 announce ANY > export: to AS21025 announce ANY > export: to AS20815 announce ANY > export: to AS20784 announce ANY > export: to AS20944 announce ANY > export: to AS16371 announce ANY > export: to AS21368 announce ANY > export: to AS21268 announce ANY > export: to AS21193 announce ANY > export: to AS20718 announce ANY > export: to AS20607 announce ANY > export: to AS20760 announce ANY > export: to AS24830 announce ANY > export: to AS21181 announce ANY > export: to AS15919 announce ANY > export: to AS25267 announce ANY > admin-c: EL729-RIPE > tech-c: BTT2-RIPE > notify: opsingguar(a)bt.es > mnt-by: BTTEL-MNT > changed: jesus.iglesias(a)bt.es > source: RIPE > ********************************************** Noticia legal Este mensaje electrónico contiene información de BT Ignite España S.A.U. que es privada y confidencial, siendo para el uso exclusivo de la persona (s) o entidades arriba mencionadas. Si usted no es el destinatario señalado, le informamos que cualquier divulgación, copia, distribución o uso de los contenidos está prohibida. Si usted ha recibido este mensaje por error, por favor borre su contenido lo antes posible. Gracias.

1 0

AW: Hierarchical authorisation failed, request forwarded to maint aine r ???
by Marcus.Ruchti＠colt.de 14 Oct '02

14 Oct '02

yes, I 've made the same experiences! 2 route objects, 2 different AS, same precision (/22). In the the RIPE DB are some of these examples... Marcus Ruchti -----Ursprüngliche Nachricht----- Von: Gert Doering [mailto:gert@space.net] Gesendet am: Montag, 14. Oktober 2002 10:38 An: Shane Kerr Cc: Ruchti, Marcus; db-wg(a)ripe.net Betreff: Re: Hierarchical authorisation failed, request forwarded to maintaine r ??? Hi, On Mon, Oct 14, 2002 at 10:23:14AM +0200, Shane Kerr wrote: > Most objects are uniquely identified by the first attribute, or > "route:" in this case. However, you must include the "origin:" > attribute for a route object. So this is: > > route: 143.58.120.0/22 > origin: AS3320 > > The object you are trying to create will be: > > route: 143.58.120.0/22 > origin: AS8220 Shane, your explanation is confusing me. There are other examples with "same route, different origin AS" in the RIPE-DB (check 194.97.0.0/16), which is sometimes necessary while migrating a network to a new origin AS. So the database should permit entry of this *new* object, instead of checking for modification permission on the *existing* object. Gert Doering -- NetMaster -- Total number of prefixes smaller than registry allocations: 48282 (47686) SpaceNet AG Mail: netmaster(a)Space.Net Joseph-Dollinger-Bogen 14 Tel : +49-89-32356-0 80807 Muenchen Fax : +49-89-32356-299

1 0

Mailing List Software Migration
by RIPE NCC WebMaster 10 Oct '02

10 Oct '02

Dear Mailing List Subscriber, The RIPE NCC will change its mailing list software from "majordomo" to "mailman" on 17 October 2002. The new mailing list software will give users more options to manage their subscriptions to the RIPE and RIPE NCC mailing lists. Additionally, this change is being made to ensure stability and continuity of mailing list management and archiving. The new mailing list software will give users a number of options using a web interface: - Subscribing and Unsubscribing to mailing lists - Reviewing general information about the mailing lists - Viewing subscriptions to mailing lists - Temporarily disabling mail delivery - Choosing between regular and digests of mailing list postings - Acknowledgements to postings The web interface will be located at the following URL: http://www.ripe.net/mailman/ As well as using the web interface, mailing list users can manage their subscription and retrieve information by using an e-mail client. Further details on this are available at the above URL. Please note that if mailing list users are already subscribed to one or more mailing lists, they do not have to take any action. Messages can still be sent to the regular mailing lists addresses and subscriptions will not have to be re-confirmed. If you have any questions about this migration, please feel free to send an e-mail to <webmaster(a)ripe.net> Kind Regards, Jeroen Bet RIPE NCC Mailing List Moderation

1 0

RIPE Whois Server version 3.1.1
by RIPE Database Administration 09 Oct '02

09 Oct '02

Dear Colleagues, [ Apologies for multiple messages. ] The RIPE NCC is pleased to announce the release of Version 3.1.1 of the RIPE Whois server. This software is compliant with both RPSL (RFC-2622) and RPS-Security (RFC-2725). This release adds several user-visible improvements: - MD5-PW authentication added. - IPv6 status changed to comply with new RIPE policy. Detailed release notes can be found at the following URL: ftp://ftp.ripe.net/ripe/dbase/software/RELEASE-NOTES-3.1.1 You can download this release by anonymous FTP from the following URL: ftp://ftp.ripe.net/ripe/dbase/software/ripe-dbase-3.1.1.tar.gz If you do not intend to use the cross-reference files or prefer to build them yourself via "make docs", you can download the source without these files by anonymous FTP from the following URL: ftp://ftp.ripe.net/ripe/dbase/software/ripe-dbase-3.1.1-nocxref.tar.gz A diff for the 3.1.1 "nocxref" version is also available, if you already have 3.1.0 and would prefer to patch that version instead, at the following URL: ftp://ftp.ripe.net/ripe/dbase/software/patch-ripe-dbase-3.1.0-nocxref-3.1.1… The client has been updated, with a minor performance increase: ftp://ftp.ripe.net/tools/ripe-whois-3.1.1.tar.gz The Object Parsing Library (OPL) standalone source has also been updated, and is identical to the library used with the release. In the future, we will be releasing the OPL at the same time as the RIPE Whois server to keep them synchronised: ftp://ftp.ripe.net/ripe/dbase/software/RPSL-OL-3.1.1.tar.gz If you have any more questions, please don't hesitate to contact <ripe-dbm(a)ripe.net> -- Shane Kerr RIPE NCC

3 6

creation of taskforce to support the ERX project (early registration xfer)
by Wilfried Woeber, UniVie/ACOnet 04 Oct '02

04 Oct '02

Dear participants in the DB and LIR WGs, as discussed and agreed in the DB-WG in Rhodes, and reported to the plenary, this is the "heads up" for the creation of a TaskForce (ERX-TF) to help in planning and test-driving the procedures and activities required to *most efficiently* perform the transfer of "early registrations" (sometimes also referred to as "legacy" IPv4 address space) from the ARIN DB to the RIPE DB.. [ For background information about the ERX Project please refer to the RIPE / RIPE NCC web pages. ] The proposed name of the TaskForce is "ERX-TF" . The preliminary and initial description of the activity is as follows: "The goal of the TF is to develop a proposal to the community of the transfer of early registration IPv4 address records (ERX) from ARIN to the RIPE NCC." For a start, I'd expect the TF to review the lessons learned from the transfer of AS Number Objects, and to investigate new or different issues with the already agreed transfer of IPv4 address space objects. The necessary next steps are 1) to ask the bigger community, by way of the mailing lists, whether there are any objections against the creation of the TF 2) to work on a refinement of the mandate, tasks to perform, and the expected results 3) to agree on a schedule, set of participants and to find a coordinator. Most of the work should be done by way of exchanging email amongst the TF Partcipants. Following up on expressions of interest as received during the RIPE43 WG session, an initial list of individuals would be put onto the mailing list. [ please see at the bottom of this mail ] Of course, if you are no longer interested - just let us know. Also, if you _are_ interested to join in - but did not or could not indicate your interest in Rhodes, please get back to us asap! Assuming that there would not be a major show-stopper, could I ask the NCC to follow up with any useful info (list name, draft schedule,...) to get us going as soon as possible? Cheers, Wilfried. Initial list of TF particpants: Havard Eidnes <he(a)uninett.no> Hank Nussbacher <hank(a)att.net.il> Gabriella Paolini <gabriella.paolini(a)garr.it> Kristian Rastas <kristian.rastas(a)sonera.com> Nigel Titley Ruediger Volk Wilfried Woeber <woeber(a)cc.univie.ac.at> _________________________________:_____________________________________ Wilfried Woeber : e-mail: Woeber(a)CC.UniVie.ac.at UniVie Computer Center - ACOnet : Tel: +43 1 4277 - 140 33 Universitaetsstrasse 7 : Fax: +43 1 4277 - 9 140 A-1010 Vienna, Austria, Europe : RIPE-DB: WW144, PGP keyID 0xF0ACB369 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

2 2

Draft Minutes DB-WG RIPE 43
by Nigel Titley 01 Oct '02

01 Oct '02

I'm sure I posted this set of minutes, but I can't find it on the mailing list. So here goes again. Errors and problems to me. I'll give it 2 weeks and then issue the final version. Nigel Database Working Group Meeting Minutes (Draft 1) RIPE-43, Sept. 9 - 13, 2002, Rhodes, GR Thursday, Sept. 12, 2002 09:00-12:30 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ A. Administrative stuff (WW, chair) . scribe (offer to take notes received from Nigel) . circulate list of participants, agenda bashing . status of minutes [ see http://www.ripe.net/ripe/wg/db/minutes/ripe-42.html ] . All presentation slides are available on the RIPE NCC web site. B. Action Items . status of actions [AP-41.1 WW] To send list of proposed updates to IRRToolSet to mailing list for WG members to vote on. Deadline 3 weeks. Expired and superceded by AP-43.6 and AP-43.9 [AP-41.2 C&W] To send their proposal to allow referencing external objects in the DB to the mailing list for discussion. Superceded by AP-43.7 and AP-43.8 [AP-41.3 RIPE-NCC] Create Documentation and BCP for IRT object. Ongoing, some work done. [AP-41.4 ALL] Create IRT object and tag inetnum for all appropriate objects. Complete. IRT objects are being created (4 so far) and no problems being reported with process. [AP-41.5 WW] To put together a group to put together a short guidance document to guide reference document writers. This team to include Ruediger. Ongoing, no action yet, nothing from Ruediger. [AP-41.6 RIPE-NCC] Put up a mailing list for the above purpose and advertise to the db-wg list. Ongoing, no action yet [AP-41.9 RIPE-NCC] To document the mirroring protocol and the operational requirements of using it. Ongoing. Some work done. [AP-41.10 RIPE-NCC] Provide nag message to maintainer owners using MAIL-FROM Complete. [AP-41.12 RIPE-NCC] Look at general password authentication methods Ongoing. No action yet. [AP-42.1 ALL] To check own data and correct inconsistencies if possible. Closed [AP-42.2 RIPE-NCC] To send instructions on multiple credentials to the DB working group mailing list. Complete. Instructions are now on the RIPE web site. [AP-42.3 RIPE-NCC] To investigate the issues involved in shadow passwords and multiple level authentication schemes. [AP-42.3 Larry Blunk] To investigate the problems of multiple hashed passwords and the possibilities of embedding an ID within the hash and to submit a proposal to the working group. A proposal came from Janos to embed such information in the remarks field. C. DB update (RIPE NCC, Andrei R.) . operations report Statistics Slightly more objects (1.6M) 80,000 users on average 18q/s average, peaking to 65q/s 2 updates per second average Still some growth in unreferenced personal objects. Need garbage collection process. 70% of queries are for contact information Updates pretty average apart from spike in mntner object caused by removal of mail-from authentication Back-end problems solved. Performance issues with long queries is still to be resolved. Otherwise scaling well User support 6 support staff shared with other software projects Introduced anti-spam filter for mail to ripe-dbm (mail routed to folder) since 20th May 2002 Added ripe-dbm ticket system (shared with hostmaster) MAIL-FROM phasing out process. 1500 maintainers missed the deadline. High fax load on DB staff. Robot now in place. Developments New MD5-PW authentication scheme. 41% of maintainers are using it. New status values for intetnum6 are not now generated. DB consistency and statistics project is now generated useful data RRCC full prototype is now up and running IRRToolset. New version 4.7.3 released. Mostly bug-fixes. The database user manual "Getting Started" has been published. (Dummies guide to the RIPE Database). Real Database user's manual is being progresses IRT Document has been published (functionality and procedures) Plans Further improving of server software (Error reporting, performance, and configuration management). Support auth checks across multiple registries IPv6 and multicast support Automatic database cleanup (if object is not referenced then delete after a certain time (following nag messages to user)). There are other possibilities [AP43.1 RIPE NCC] Look at other possibilities for database cleanup. Additional user support (Documentation, Sync and Web interface) Main Events Improvements in security (MD5 and MAIL-FROM) Documentation and User support Web and syncupdate interfaces. D Web interface and Syncupdates for DB (RIPE NCC, Can Bican) Currently updates are via email Hard to automate Difficult for beginner Syncupdates allows online updates to database, web interface built on top of this TCP based Extensible, maintainable, same functionality, easy to use. Minimal client (HTTP) can be used Notifications are sent by email as usual WebUpdates is a prototype of an update client which allows adding, deleting and updating of an object. Only password authentication. Passwords are stored via cookies. No PGP authentication Multi-line attributes not properly handled Only one object may be updated in a submission All suggestions and feature requests are welcomed. http://webupdates-test.ripe.net http://syncupdates-test.ripe.net Probably one month before coming into production (syncupdates) Webupdates can be earlier, but please send comments to the db tools email address. E. Database Consistency Project Statistics (RIPE NCC, Shane) This refers to data that can be seen as incorrect merely by looking at the database itself (eg not routing inconsistencies) Changes in rules Abandoned data User error Examples Non handle admin-c Syntactic errors Missing or incorrect status attributes Unreferenced person objects Unreferenced maintainer objects CSIRT for no networks Unreferenced PGP key Also non-authoritative Data Prehistoric inetnum (non-RIPE) Objects in unprotected space Possibly unauthorized route objects Abandoned objects Unresponsive maintainers (both LIR and non-LIR) Outdated contacts Solutions Reports RRCC reports Database consistency reports Really only helpful for actively maintained objects Restrict Input Many of these checks already but will soon include integrity checks and RPSS checks Does not address current problems Revocation Allow higher level maintainer to delete objects lower in the hierarchy. (Currently can only be done by ripe-dbm). Unresponsive maintainers? Use another maintainer, or delete maintainer? Cleanups RIPE NCC implementation of WG decision Has been done in the past successfully. Discussion Normally starts on the mailing list, generating proposals which are then voted on at the RIPE meeting. Opinions Why spend a lot of resources to clean it up? It will never be completely clean? Only 5% garbage. Difference between structural problems and operational problems. Garbage can prevent the generation of accurate reverse delegation zone files, and address allocation reports. Even 5% garbage can render these useless. Registration of contact information can be really useful, even if not related to operational data. Should we be removing this data if it is useful? However, privacy issues now pertain to this data. We should also be wary of using the DB as a general key-server. F. "Early Registration Transfer" (ERX) Project (Andrei, RIPE NCC) . Introduction ASN and IP registration inherited by ARIN from Internic Pre-RIR Non-geographical . Goals and Phases Transfer of DB records and conflict resolution Transfer of associated documentation Phase 1 ASN registrations Phase 2 IPv4 registration . AS number migration ARIN only (419 ASNs) just created and protected in the RIPE DB Completed 21st August ARIN & RIPE (conflicting data, no RP) (87 ASNs) merge and lock. Resolve conflict and then unlock Completed 21st August ARIN & RIPE (with RP specifications) (177 ASNs) manual 2 week conflict resolution prior to transfer Completed 21st August 30% of notification emails bounced. Lessons Don't use August..... Often no evidence. Makes resolution very difficult in cases of dispute. Do not lock objects. They may be in use. Some people only wake up at the deadline . IP V4 migration 47 /8s to be transferred Conflicts are likely to be more complex. Transfer of DNS reverse delegations. Group 1 (ARIN only) Create and protect in the RIPE DB Group 2 (Exact match between ARIN and RIPE, except for contact and description) Resolve conflicts and then merge (do not lock) Group 3 (RIPE does not match ARIN) If NCC allocation then keep in RIPE Otherwise delete (after response time) . Discussion Thanks for the RIPE NCC from ARIN for their cooperation Human matching of records cannot necessarily be done by machine. Records that obviously match on visual inspection may not be easily matchable automatically. Two weeks (especially in August) is not enough time to resolve conflicts [AP43.3 RIPE NCC] Provide detailed action plan to the WG before implementing Phase 2. Trying to obtain authorization from contacts in the ARIN database is likely to be difficult, as in many cases the authoritative data is the RIPE database. Hence it may be necessary to extend the time for resolution of conflicts. What happens to IPv4 objects that are in an undefined state after the process? They will remain locked until the holder emerges. At which point the appropriate procedures will be invoked. Is there any chance of getting information about what IP objects will be transferred, prior to the actual transfer process? [AP43.4 RIPE NCC] To produce a list of requirements for such a list. Is there a possibility of automatically aggregating eg /24s in the ARIN database to the appropriate aggregated object in the RIPE DB? Probably not, as there don't seem to be many such objects. This will probably be a manual process. A suggestion that more resource be allocated to the IPv4 migration than was allocated to the ASN migration. [AP43.5 WW] Set up a task force to go through some test cases before hand. It should report on the mailing lists (DB and LIR) within 4 weeks. (Wilfried Woeber, Nigel Titley, Joao Luis Damas at least) Are there any requirements from the outside for target dates? No fixed date, but should get it done as quickly as possible. G. IRRToolSet Development Brainstorming (+ external refs?) . how to find out who is using what? A few people are... one at least is using a home-brew set of tools It was noted that those who are using the toolset are using it together with other tools. This may have to be taken into account. Some things are missing eg Support for zebra [AP-43.6 ALL] Those who have requirements to send to IRRToolSet(a)ripe.net What tools do people find useful? [AP-43.9 RIPE NCC] To try and track down some of the outdated references to the IRRToolset out on the web and get them corrected. . External reference Who needs it? Need at a minimum things like AS-sets which are referred to in the RFC. Need a list of things for which it makes sense and those for which it would be insane (Ruediger Volk) The status of external reference in the RPSS RFC is "out of document scope", although a possible mechanism is described. There is a clear need for this, and the C&W registry is using this syntax. It is also needed in order forms etc (and is already included in some forms from some providers). The RPSS working group needs waking up to properly resolve this issue. Should the DB be prepared to accept this syntax? No real performance issues (Andrei) and not a real problem. The RPSL-dist informal proposal suggests a new "registry" object. [AP-43.7 Ruediger Volk] To produce a short report on what would be useful and how to start. [AP-43.8 RIPE NCC] To investigate how much effort would be required to add this functionality to the RIPE DB. Y. Input from other WGs . None Z. AOB: . Organi[sz]ation object proposal Examples would be a local registry which could be well described in such an object. . IRT object There are only 4 such objects. However no one has had problems creating

1 0

TEST database maintenance
by Andrei Robachevsky 01 Oct '02

01 Oct '02

Dear Colleagues, We plan to have a maintenance of our TEST database server on 7 October, starting from 20:00 till 9:00 next day, 8 October. During this time the following services will be unavailable: - TEST database for queries and updates. - Webupdates and Syncupdates prototypes. - RRCC reports and statistics. - DB Consistency reports and statistics. We apologise for any inconvenience this may cause. Regards, Andrei Robachevsky RIPE NCC

2 2