Victor Reijs <Victor.Reijs@SURFnet.nl> writes * Hello all of you, * * Below you find the DRAFT entries for CLNS domain for SURFnet bv. There are * still some open ends: * - I introduced the guardian list: clns-domain-guardian. This because the IP * and CLNS guardians coudl be different persons/organisations. What is the * idea of RIPE for this? I am not quite sure what you mean here, every object with a guardian can contain a different mailbox, has nothing to do with mailing lists. * - I changed the responsibility of entry with relation to my earlier mail. * It now seems to be more alligned with the existing IP world. Not quite sure what you mean here. * - Marcel, are you still pushing ISO to include the top-levels of NSAP * domains in the RIPe database? Together with the DUtch NSO (NNI) we could * jointly put presure on ISO. Currently the database does not accept anything smaller than xx.xxxx as a prefix. If you want this changed, let me know. * - I am trying to get the Dutch NSO (NNI) involved in their entries. * - syntax checking is, I assume, not yet their (including logical checking, * like bis info, domain info, routing info, etc.). The CLNS coordination * group will have to look at that. Marcel? All these entries will bounce with syntax errors, most of them basic RIPE database syntax errors. Let me show a few: * dom-prefix: 39.528f * dom-name: DCC NSAP address scheme for the Netherlands (binary DSP syntax) * desc: NNI * desc: Postbus 5059 * desc: 2600 GB Delft * desc: The Netherlands * admin-c: someone from NNI * guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl * source: RIPE * changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 * remark: Just to start the hierarchy in the RIPE database, this * record * remark: has been temporarily made by someone else then NNI. * remark: In future this record must be ownded by NNI. dom-name should be one word, will be used as a key. So, if you switch the first line of your descr with the dom-name, it will work nicely. Also desc should be descr, admin-c AND tech-c are mandatory * dom-prefix: 39.528f.1100.001.10 * dom-name: CLNS domain of KUB * descr: KUB * descr: Hogeschoollaan 225 * descr: 5037 GC Tilburg * descr: The Netherlands * admin-c: Victor.Reijs@surfnet.nl * tech-c: martin@kub.nl * guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl * source: RIPE * changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 Same problem with dom-name here. admin-c and tech-c should be person names, not email addresses. Also, newlines are not aligned in the middle of an object. A full syntax check is below. -Marten
Summary of the update <<<
Errors 17 Warnings 0 Ok's 0 Total 17 dom-prefix: 39 dom-name: AFI for ISO-DCC NSAP address scheme (binary DSP syntax) admin-c: someone from ISO guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl remarks: Just to start the hierarchy in the RIPE database, this record remarks: has been temporarily made by someone else then ISO. remarks: In future this record must be ownded by ISO. changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 source: RIPE *ERROR*: mandatory field "tech-c" missing dom-prefix: 38 dom-name: AFI for ISO-DCC NSAP address scheme (decimal DSP syntax) admin-c: someone from ISO guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl remarks: Just to start the hierarchy in the RIPE database, this record remarks: has been temporarily made by someone else then ISO. remarks: In future this record must be ownded by ISO. changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 source: RIPE *ERROR*: mandatory field "tech-c" missing dom-prefix: 39.528f dom-name: DCC NSAP address scheme for the Netherlands (binary DSP syntax) admin-c: someone from NNI guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl remarks: Just to start the hierarchy in the RIPE database, this record remarks: has been temporarily made by someone else then NNI. remarks: In future this record must be ownded by NNI. changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 source: RIPE *ERROR*: attribute "desc" unknown in dom-prefix object *ERROR*: multiple lines not allowed for: "" *ERROR*: mandatory field "tech-c" missing dom-prefix: 38.528 dom-name: DCC NSAP address scheme for the Netherlands (decimal DSP syntax *ERROR*: mandatory field "changed" missing *ERROR*: mandatory field "source" missing *ERROR*: mandatory field "tech-c" missing *ERROR*: mandatory field "admin-c" missing rm: Just to start the hierarchy in the RIPE database, this record rm: has been temporarily made by someone else then NNI. rm: In future this record must be ownded by NNI. ch: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 desc: NNI desc: Postbus 5059 desc: 2600 GB Delft desc: The Netherlands so: RIPE ac: someone from NNI gd: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl *ERROR*: Unknown object type dom-prefix: 38.5281.100 dom-name: SURFnet-CLNS domain (decimal DSP syntax) descr: SURFnet bv descr: P.O. Box 19035 descr: 3501 DA Urecht descr: The Netherlands admin-c: Victor.Reijs@surfnet.nl tech-c: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 source: RIPE *ERROR*: syntax error in "tech-c" *ERROR*: syntax error in "admin-c" *ERROR*: illegal dom-name name dom-prefix: 39.528f.1100 dom-name: SURFnet-CLNS domain (binary DSP syntax) descr: SURFnet bv descr: P.O. Box 19035 descr: 3501 DA Urecht descr: The Netherlands admin-c: Victor.Reijs.surfnet.nl tech-c: Victor.Reijs@surfnet.nl guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 source: RIPE *ERROR*: syntax error in "tech-c" *ERROR*: illegal dom-name name dom-prefix: 39.528f.1100.1000.10 dom-name: CLNS domain for DECnet IV and DECnet/OSI descr: SURFnet bv descr: P.O. Box 19035 descr: 3501 DA Urecht descr: The Netherlands admin-c: Victor.Reijs@surfnet.nl tech-c: pve@kub.nl guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 source: RIPE *ERROR*: syntax error in "tech-c" *ERROR*: syntax error in "admin-c" *ERROR*: illegal dom-name name dom-prefix: 39.528f.1100.1000.20 descr: CLNS domain for SURFnet CLNS test backbone descr: SURFnet bv descr: P.O. Box 19035 descr: 3501 DA Urecht descr: The Netherlands bis: 39.528f.1100.1000.2000.0000.0001.0000.0c04.29b4.00 39.528f.1103 dom-in: 39.528f.1103 100 ANY AND NOT 39.528f.1100.0009.10 dom-in: 39.528f.1100000910 100 39528f1100000910 dom-out: 39.528f.1103 39528f1100 AND NOT 39.528f.1100.0009.10 dom-out: 39.528f.1100.0009.10 39.528f.1100 default: 39.528f.1103 10 admin-c: Victor.Reijs@surfnet.nl tech-c: henk_steenman@sara.nl guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 source: RIPE *ERROR*: mandatory field "dom-name" missing dom-prefix: 39.528f.1100.1000.30 dom-name: CLNS domain for SURFnet CLNS production backbone descr: SURFnet bv descr: P.O. Box 19035 descr: 3501 DA Urecht descr: The Netherlands admin-c: Victor.Reijs@surfnet.nl tech-c: henk_steenman@sara.nl guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 source: RIPE *ERROR*: syntax error in "tech-c" *ERROR*: syntax error in "admin-c" *ERROR*: illegal dom-name name dom-prefix: 39.528f.1100.0009.10 dom-name: CLNS domain of SARA descr: SARA descr: Kruislaan 415 descr: 1098 SJ Amsterdam descr: The Netherlands admin-c: Victor.Reijs@surfnet.nl tech-c: Henk_steenman@sara.nl guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 source: RIPE *ERROR*: syntax error in "tech-c" *ERROR*: syntax error in "admin-c" *ERROR*: illegal dom-name name dom-prefix: 39.528f.1100.0000.90 dom-name: CLNS domain of TU Delft descr: TU Delft descr: Michiel de Ruyterweg 10-12 descr: 2628 BA Delft descr: The Netherlands admin-c: Victor.Reijs@surfnet.nl tech-c: B.Zorn@ET.TUDelft.NL guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 source: RIPE *ERROR*: syntax error in "tech-c" *ERROR*: syntax error in "admin-c" *ERROR*: illegal dom-name name dom-prefix: 39.528f.1100.0012.30 admin-c: Victor.Reijs@surfnet.nl tech-c: Victor.Reijs@surfnet.nl guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 source: RIPE *ERROR*: attribute "dim-name" unknown in dom-prefix object *ERROR*: attribute "desc" unknown in dom-prefix object *ERROR*: multiple lines not allowed for: "" *ERROR*: mandatory field "dom-name" missing dom-prefix: 39.528f.1100.0009.10 dom-name: PTT Research - TUBA/CLNS Testnetwork descr: PTT Research descr: St. Paulusstraat 4 descr: P.O. Box 421 descr: Leidschendam descr: The Netherlands bis: 39.528f.1100.0009.1000.0000.0040.0000.0c03.df7d.00 *ERROR*: mandatory field "changed" missing *ERROR*: mandatory field "source" missing *ERROR*: mandatory field "tech-c" missing *ERROR*: mandatory field "admin-c" missing ch: A.A.L.Reijnierse@research.ptt.nl 940228 so: RIPE tc: A.A.L.Reijnierse@research.ptt.nl bi: 39.528f.1100.0009.1000.0000.0040.0000.0c04.5eaf.00 39.528f.1103 ac: Victor.Reijs@surfnet.nl do: 39.528f.1100.1000.20 39.528f.1100.0009.10 do: 39.528f.1103 39.528f.1100.0009.10 df: 39.528f.1103 10 dm: 39.528f.1100.1000.20 39.528f.1100 dm: 39.528f.1103 ANY AND NOT 39.528f.1100 gd: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl *ERROR*: Unknown object type dom-prefix: 39.528f.1100.001.10 dom-name: CLNS domain of KUB descr: KUB descr: Hogeschoollaan 225 descr: 5037 GC Tilburg descr: The Netherlands admin-c: Victor.Reijs@surfnet.nl tech-c: martin@kub.nl guardian: clns-domain-guardian@nic.surfnet.nl changed: victor.reijs@surfnet.nl 940228 source: RIPE *ERROR*: illegal NSAP prefix format in "dom-prefix" *ERROR*: syntax error in "tech-c" *ERROR*: syntax error in "admin-c" *ERROR*: illegal dom-name name