* Denis Walker:
The discussions around the abuse handling in the Anti Abuse Working Group have made it clear that this will not be personal data. So these ROLE objects will be available without the limits that personal data is subject to. They will also be available in the bulk data dumps. This is why we propose to allow an "abuse-c:" attribute to reference only a ROLE object and not a PERSON object. As Kaveh said, the ROLE object was not designed to, and should not, hold personal data.
Does this mean that you will publish a ROLE object in the bulk dump once it is referenced from an abuse-c: field? Right now, you're redacting ROLE objects—but as Kaveh said, ROLE objects should not contain personal data, so there shouldn't be a reason for redacting them. That's where my confusion comes from, I guess.