Deprecation of DBConstat service
Dear colleagues, The RIPE NCC has carried out a thorough review of DBConstat, a service to check consistency of data in the RIPE Database and produce statistics. It was written over ten years ago and has changed little over that period. The current software is unmaintainable now. The results of this review are published on RIPE Labs: https://labs.ripe.net/Members/denis/review-of-dbconstat The review showed that this service produces a series of almost flat line graphs and provides an interactive service barely used by anyone and resulting in no significant improvement in data quality in the RIPE Database. The RIPE NCC believes this is not the way to address the few outstanding inconsistencies reported by this service. We therefore intend to deprecate this service, then investigate and address the remaining inconsistencies using other methods, as discussed in the article on RIPE Labs. If anyone has any concerns about this service, please reply to the mailing list within the next two weeks. Regards, Denis Walker Business Analyst RIPE NCC Database Group
Dear Colleagues, The RIPE NCC announced last week an intention to deprecate the DBConstat service. The service will be de-commisioned at the end of next week. If anyone has any concerns about this service, please reply to the mailing list within the week. Regards, Denis Walker Business Analyst RIPE NCC Database Group On 21/06/12:26 3:20 PM, Denis Walker wrote:
Dear colleagues,
The RIPE NCC has carried out a thorough review of DBConstat, a service to check consistency of data in the RIPE Database and produce statistics. It was written over ten years ago and has changed little over that period. The current software is unmaintainable now. The results of this review are published on RIPE Labs: https://labs.ripe.net/Members/denis/review-of-dbconstat
The review showed that this service produces a series of almost flat line graphs and provides an interactive service barely used by anyone and resulting in no significant improvement in data quality in the RIPE Database.
The RIPE NCC believes this is not the way to address the few outstanding inconsistencies reported by this service. We therefore intend to deprecate this service, then investigate and address the remaining inconsistencies using other methods, as discussed in the article on RIPE Labs.
If anyone has any concerns about this service, please reply to the mailing list within the next two weeks.
Regards,
Denis Walker Business Analyst RIPE NCC Database Group
On 28/06/2012 14:44, Denis Walker wrote:
Dear Colleagues,
The RIPE NCC announced last week an intention to deprecate the DBConstat service.
The service will be de-commisioned at the end of next week. If anyone has any concerns about this service, please reply to the mailing list within the week.
Regards,
Denis Walker Business Analyst RIPE NCC Database Group
On 21/06/12:26 3:20 PM, Denis Walker wrote:
Dear colleagues,
The RIPE NCC has carried out a thorough review of DBConstat, a service to check consistency of data in the RIPE Database and produce statistics. It was written over ten years ago and has changed little over that period. The current software is unmaintainable now. The results of this review are published on RIPE Labs: https://labs.ripe.net/Members/denis/review-of-dbconstat
The review showed that this service produces a series of almost flat line graphs and provides an interactive service barely used by anyone and resulting in no significant improvement in data quality in the RIPE Database.
The RIPE NCC believes this is not the way to address the few outstanding inconsistencies reported by this service. We therefore intend to deprecate this service, then investigate and address the remaining inconsistencies using other methods, as discussed in the article on RIPE Labs.
If anyone has any concerns about this service, please reply to the mailing list within the next two weeks.
We haven't had any response. If you want to keep DBConstat then you have just a few more hours to note the fact.
Nigel DB-WG Co-chair
participants (2)
-
Denis Walker -
Nigel Titley