probe tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected"
Hi, I have (once again) problems with my probe (probeID: 24102). This time, it got tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected". The strange thing is that I did not touch anything on my router when this happened and did not change any other configuration... This probe is located in Luxembourg. I now brought it to Belgium and plugged it into the router I have here. Nothing changed. Furthermore, here in Belgium, its 3rd light is slowly blinking, which let's suppose that it gets tuck in the network-testing phase. Anybody knows how to fix this? (I already had some problems with that probe ("system: Hardware problem suspected") but I could solve them thanks to a hint given by a user.) My worst problem is that, due to this issue, we have difficulties earning enough credits for our research... So I would be really happy if this problem could be solved easily :( Thanks! Sarah
I've found that moving the probe between networks can cause this. Mine took almost 48 hours to return to normal operations. Please email me off list with your Atlas email address and I can transfer you some credits for your research :) On 16 February 2016 at 18:29, <sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be> wrote:
Hi,
I have (once again) problems with my probe (probeID: 24102). This time, it got tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected". The strange thing is that I did not touch anything on my router when this happened and did not change any other configuration... This probe is located in Luxembourg. I now brought it to Belgium and plugged it into the router I have here. Nothing changed. Furthermore, here in Belgium, its 3rd light is slowly blinking, which let's suppose that it gets tuck in the network-testing phase.
Anybody knows how to fix this?
(I already had some problems with that probe ("system: Hardware problem suspected") but I could solve them thanks to a hint given by a user.)
My worst problem is that, due to this issue, we have difficulties earning enough credits for our research... So I would be really happy if this problem could be solved easily :(
Thanks!
Sarah
Hi Sarah, The tagging is done by heuristic that analyzes the probe connection attempts, SOS, timing between them and some other attributes like messages about flash drive. It has to have a quite large window for looking into data and it can take up to a few days for addressing a probe to a special controller if needed and resetting tags. In your case I see that it was disconnected at 2016-02-12 12:26:09. Up till this time your probe had no problem connecting regservers and controllers (tcp/443). After that time I see only SOS (DNS (tcp|udp)/53). That suggests the network problem with the highest probability - DNS is open but tcp/443 is closed. The lowest probability has the hardware problem (flash drive) in this case. Please use the tag as a suggestion where to begin your local diagnostics. If the network is good you can try to reinit the flash drive. wbr /vty On 2/16/16 7:29 PM, sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be wrote:
Hi,
I have (once again) problems with my probe (probeID: 24102). This time, it got tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected". The strange thing is that I did not touch anything on my router when this happened and did not change any other configuration... This probe is located in Luxembourg. I now brought it to Belgium and plugged it into the router I have here. Nothing changed. Furthermore, here in Belgium, its 3rd light is slowly blinking, which let's suppose that it gets tuck in the network-testing phase.
Anybody knows how to fix this?
(I already had some problems with that probe ("system: Hardware problem suspected") but I could solve them thanks to a hint given by a user.)
My worst problem is that, due to this issue, we have difficulties earning enough credits for our research... So I would be really happy if this problem could be solved easily :(
Thanks!
Sarah
Hi Viktor, The network looks good. The last time I had a problem with my probe, the flash drive was the guilty one. So, as you suggested, I will reinit the flash drive and see how it goes. I will keep you updated. Thanks for the hints! Sarah ----- Mail original ----- De: "Viktor Naumov" <vnaumov@ripe.net> À: "sarah wassermann" <sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be> Cc: ripe-atlas@ripe.net Envoyé: Mercredi 17 Février 2016 10:53:02 Objet: Re: [atlas] probe tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected" Hi Sarah, The tagging is done by heuristic that analyzes the probe connection attempts, SOS, timing between them and some other attributes like messages about flash drive. It has to have a quite large window for looking into data and it can take up to a few days for addressing a probe to a special controller if needed and resetting tags. In your case I see that it was disconnected at 2016-02-12 12:26:09. Up till this time your probe had no problem connecting regservers and controllers (tcp/443). After that time I see only SOS (DNS (tcp|udp)/53). That suggests the network problem with the highest probability - DNS is open but tcp/443 is closed. The lowest probability has the hardware problem (flash drive) in this case. Please use the tag as a suggestion where to begin your local diagnostics. If the network is good you can try to reinit the flash drive. wbr /vty On 2/16/16 7:29 PM, sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be wrote:
Hi,
I have (once again) problems with my probe (probeID: 24102). This time, it got tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected". The strange thing is that I did not touch anything on my router when this happened and did not change any other configuration... This probe is located in Luxembourg. I now brought it to Belgium and plugged it into the router I have here. Nothing changed. Furthermore, here in Belgium, its 3rd light is slowly blinking, which let's suppose that it gets tuck in the network-testing phase.
Anybody knows how to fix this?
(I already had some problems with that probe ("system: Hardware problem suspected") but I could solve them thanks to a hint given by a user.)
My worst problem is that, due to this issue, we have difficulties earning enough credits for our research... So I would be really happy if this problem could be solved easily :(
Thanks!
Sarah
Hi Viktor, I tried all your pieces of advice, but my probe is still disconnected (with 3rd light slowly blinking). I also attempted to connect it to my router in Liège, on which another probe is also connected and working fine, but even there the probe didn't come back to life. Thanks to several generous credit-donations, I don't need credits anymore, but can I send the probe somewhere so that it can be fixed? There are not that many probes here in Luxembourg and I would be happy to host a working probe to help extend the network! Best regards, Sarah ----- Mail original ----- De: "Viktor Naumov" <vnaumov@ripe.net> À: "sarah wassermann" <sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be> Cc: ripe-atlas@ripe.net Envoyé: Mercredi 17 Février 2016 10:53:02 Objet: Re: [atlas] probe tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected" Hi Sarah, The tagging is done by heuristic that analyzes the probe connection attempts, SOS, timing between them and some other attributes like messages about flash drive. It has to have a quite large window for looking into data and it can take up to a few days for addressing a probe to a special controller if needed and resetting tags. In your case I see that it was disconnected at 2016-02-12 12:26:09. Up till this time your probe had no problem connecting regservers and controllers (tcp/443). After that time I see only SOS (DNS (tcp|udp)/53). That suggests the network problem with the highest probability - DNS is open but tcp/443 is closed. The lowest probability has the hardware problem (flash drive) in this case. Please use the tag as a suggestion where to begin your local diagnostics. If the network is good you can try to reinit the flash drive. wbr /vty On 2/16/16 7:29 PM, sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be wrote:
Hi,
I have (once again) problems with my probe (probeID: 24102). This time, it got tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected". The strange thing is that I did not touch anything on my router when this happened and did not change any other configuration... This probe is located in Luxembourg. I now brought it to Belgium and plugged it into the router I have here. Nothing changed. Furthermore, here in Belgium, its 3rd light is slowly blinking, which let's suppose that it gets tuck in the network-testing phase.
Anybody knows how to fix this?
(I already had some problems with that probe ("system: Hardware problem suspected") but I could solve them thanks to a hint given by a user.)
My worst problem is that, due to this issue, we have difficulties earning enough credits for our research... So I would be really happy if this problem could be solved easily :(
Thanks!
Sarah
Hi Sarah, Did you try to boot the probe without USB drive plugged in and replugging it back in 10 minutes while being powered? Did you try to replace the USB drive with a new one with capacity >= 4G? If you tried everything please write to atlas@ripe.net it will create a ticket and we will look further what we can do together about it. Cheers! /vty On 3/6/16 12:25 PM, sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be wrote:
Hi Viktor,
I tried all your pieces of advice, but my probe is still disconnected (with 3rd light slowly blinking). I also attempted to connect it to my router in Liège, on which another probe is also connected and working fine, but even there the probe didn't come back to life.
Thanks to several generous credit-donations, I don't need credits anymore, but can I send the probe somewhere so that it can be fixed? There are not that many probes here in Luxembourg and I would be happy to host a working probe to help extend the network!
Best regards,
Sarah
----- Mail original ----- De: "Viktor Naumov" <vnaumov@ripe.net> À: "sarah wassermann" <sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be> Cc: ripe-atlas@ripe.net Envoyé: Mercredi 17 Février 2016 10:53:02 Objet: Re: [atlas] probe tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected"
Hi Sarah,
The tagging is done by heuristic that analyzes the probe connection attempts, SOS, timing between them and some other attributes like messages about flash drive. It has to have a quite large window for looking into data and it can take up to a few days for addressing a probe to a special controller if needed and resetting tags.
In your case I see that it was disconnected at 2016-02-12 12:26:09. Up till this time your probe had no problem connecting regservers and controllers (tcp/443). After that time I see only SOS (DNS (tcp|udp)/53). That suggests the network problem with the highest probability - DNS is open but tcp/443 is closed. The lowest probability has the hardware problem (flash drive) in this case.
Please use the tag as a suggestion where to begin your local diagnostics. If the network is good you can try to reinit the flash drive.
wbr
/vty
On 2/16/16 7:29 PM, sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be wrote:
Hi,
I have (once again) problems with my probe (probeID: 24102). This time, it got tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected". The strange thing is that I did not touch anything on my router when this happened and did not change any other configuration... This probe is located in Luxembourg. I now brought it to Belgium and plugged it into the router I have here. Nothing changed. Furthermore, here in Belgium, its 3rd light is slowly blinking, which let's suppose that it gets tuck in the network-testing phase.
Anybody knows how to fix this?
(I already had some problems with that probe ("system: Hardware problem suspected") but I could solve them thanks to a hint given by a user.)
My worst problem is that, due to this issue, we have difficulties earning enough credits for our research... So I would be really happy if this problem could be solved easily :(
Thanks!
Sarah
Hi Viktor, Sorry for my long silence. I tried everything related to the USB drive you suggested, but nothing helped. Even worse, the probe corrupted one of my USB drives and I had to recover it with diskpart. (The USB drive worked fine just before the test, but it became unreadable afterwards and I had only 1 GB at my disposal, whereas it was a USB drive with a capacity of 16 GB) Do you have any other ideas to fix this probe or should I simply order a new one? Thanks! Sarah ----- Mail original ----- De: "Viktor Naumov" <vnaumov@ripe.net> À: "sarah wassermann" <sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be> Cc: ripe-atlas@ripe.net, hank@efes.iucc.ac.il Envoyé: Lundi 7 Mars 2016 08:46:26 Objet: Re: [atlas] probe tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected" Hi Sarah, Did you try to boot the probe without USB drive plugged in and replugging it back in 10 minutes while being powered? Did you try to replace the USB drive with a new one with capacity >= 4G? If you tried everything please write to atlas@ripe.net it will create a ticket and we will look further what we can do together about it. Cheers! /vty On 3/6/16 12:25 PM, sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be wrote:
Hi Viktor,
I tried all your pieces of advice, but my probe is still disconnected (with 3rd light slowly blinking). I also attempted to connect it to my router in Liège, on which another probe is also connected and working fine, but even there the probe didn't come back to life.
Thanks to several generous credit-donations, I don't need credits anymore, but can I send the probe somewhere so that it can be fixed? There are not that many probes here in Luxembourg and I would be happy to host a working probe to help extend the network!
Best regards,
Sarah
----- Mail original ----- De: "Viktor Naumov" <vnaumov@ripe.net> À: "sarah wassermann" <sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be> Cc: ripe-atlas@ripe.net Envoyé: Mercredi 17 Février 2016 10:53:02 Objet: Re: [atlas] probe tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected"
Hi Sarah,
The tagging is done by heuristic that analyzes the probe connection attempts, SOS, timing between them and some other attributes like messages about flash drive. It has to have a quite large window for looking into data and it can take up to a few days for addressing a probe to a special controller if needed and resetting tags.
In your case I see that it was disconnected at 2016-02-12 12:26:09. Up till this time your probe had no problem connecting regservers and controllers (tcp/443). After that time I see only SOS (DNS (tcp|udp)/53). That suggests the network problem with the highest probability - DNS is open but tcp/443 is closed. The lowest probability has the hardware problem (flash drive) in this case.
Please use the tag as a suggestion where to begin your local diagnostics. If the network is good you can try to reinit the flash drive.
wbr
/vty
On 2/16/16 7:29 PM, sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be wrote:
Hi,
I have (once again) problems with my probe (probeID: 24102). This time, it got tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected". The strange thing is that I did not touch anything on my router when this happened and did not change any other configuration... This probe is located in Luxembourg. I now brought it to Belgium and plugged it into the router I have here. Nothing changed. Furthermore, here in Belgium, its 3rd light is slowly blinking, which let's suppose that it gets tuck in the network-testing phase.
Anybody knows how to fix this?
(I already had some problems with that probe ("system: Hardware problem suspected") but I could solve them thanks to a hint given by a user.)
My worst problem is that, due to this issue, we have difficulties earning enough credits for our research... So I would be really happy if this problem could be solved easily :(
Thanks!
Sarah
Hi Sarah, all, On 16-feb.-16 19:29, sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be wrote:
(I already had some problems with that probe ("system: Hardware problem suspected") but I could solve them thanks to a hint given by a user.)
Thanks for keeping your probe alive - it will help increase the coverage in Belgium, and enable other users to ask for the measurements from Belgian point of view!
My worst problem is that, due to this issue, we have difficulties earning enough credits for our research...
We will reply to your message off-the-list about extra credits. Usually, we are quite generous when it comes to supporting students & researchers with credits to spend when producing papers. Regards, Vesna
Thank you Vesna, someone from the RIPE team contacted me to help me out! Sarah ----- Mail original ----- De: "Vesna Manojlovic" <BECHA@ripe.net> À: "sarah wassermann" <sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be>, ripe-atlas@ripe.net Envoyé: Jeudi 18 Février 2016 15:35:11 Objet: Re: [atlas] probe tagged as "system: Firewall problem suspected" Hi Sarah, all, On 16-feb.-16 19:29, sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be wrote:
(I already had some problems with that probe ("system: Hardware problem suspected") but I could solve them thanks to a hint given by a user.)
Thanks for keeping your probe alive - it will help increase the coverage in Belgium, and enable other users to ask for the measurements from Belgian point of view!
My worst problem is that, due to this issue, we have difficulties earning enough credits for our research...
We will reply to your message off-the-list about extra credits. Usually, we are quite generous when it comes to supporting students & researchers with credits to spend when producing papers. Regards, Vesna
participants (4)
-
Alistair Mackenzie
-
sarah.wassermann@student.ulg.ac.be
-
Vesna Manojlovic
-
Viktor Naumov